A church divided, together
We explore the effect of the Aug. 21, 2009 vote allowing gay pastors to serve as clergy in the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America through the stories of Lutherans in the Public Insight Network.

Coming together

Amalia Vagts
Decorah, Iowa
"They are some of the best and brightest pastors in the Lutheran tradition. Their story is one of finding joy and community in exile."
↓ In their words
Ordination of Rev. Steve Keiser
The ordination of Rev. Steve Keiser, January of 2008 in Philadelphia, Pa. was conducted within the Lutheran confessional tradition by many members of the ELCA. It occurred outside the rules of the ELCA and is thus considered an "extraordinary" or "irregular" ordination. Pastor Steve currently serves as associate pastor at Lutheran Church of the Holy Communion, Philadelphia, PA (Photo courtesy of Amalia Vagts)

Amalia Vagts of Good Shepherd Lutheran in Decorah, Iowa is executive director of the Extraordinary Lutheran Ministries, an organization that for more than 20 years has helped gay and lesbian pastors kicked off of church rosters because of their sexuality find churches where they can serve.

"[These pastors] have passionate and moving stories about remaining devoted to a church that has continued to shut the door on them; and about finding deep joy in ministry despite the church's discrimination.

"They have continued to serve within the ELCA, risking discipline for themselves or their congregations. They have served in the parish, in nursing homes, in youth groups, and on the street. They are some of the best and brightest pastors in the Lutheran tradition.

"Their story is one of finding joy and community in exile."

Michael Kunz
St. Louis, Mo.
"Although the ELCA may have lost some members because of this vote, it is because we have chosen to be more open and welcoming..."
↓ In their words
Ordination of Rev. Steve Keiser
Michael Kunz and his wife Deborah Bohlmann at the confirmation of their daughter in May 2008. (Left to right: Deborah Bohlmann, Miriam Bohlmann Kunz, Michael Kunz, John Bohlmann Kunz) (Photo courtesy of Michael Kunz)

Michael Kunz and his family attend Bethel Lutheran Church in University City, Mo. The vote affirmed their congregation's policy of inclusiveness.

"People at our congregation, including me, feel validated in our decision 15 years ago to actively and openly welcome gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered individuals.

"I have discovered that I feel strongly about oppression in all its forms.

"I believe that although the ELCA may have lost some members because of this vote, it is because we have chosen to be more open and welcoming, less fear-mongering, and truer to the Gospel of Jesus Christ.

"That can only be a good thing."