Commentary
Maybe we should move toward a right to rent guns
By Bob von Sternberg
Bob von Sternberg was a reporter at the Star Tribune for 27 years, covering politics and other topics. He lives in Minneapolis.
My daughter, an avid news consumer halfway into her 10th year, came across the Colorado massacre Friday morning when she fired up the TV to play her Wii.
She didn't linger over the CNN bulletins, but peppered my wife and me with questions for the rest of the day about what on earth had happened in Aurora. This was, after all, the first mass shooting that had ever creased her consciousness.
At one point, she offered a suggestion: Nobody but police officers or hunters needs a gun. If you want to go hunting, you could rent one.
Huh. I've never heard such a succinct, sensible gun control strategy for a country that's awash in firearms and a complete outlier in the developed world.
Molly's not a stranger to guns. Her grandfather is an avid hunter who has long guns. A neighbor and friend is a local cop who keeps his sidearm in the house when he's off duty. But Molly and her younger brother feel safe in both places because the guns are safely locked up, out of reach to anyone but their owners.
My daughter offered up an epiphany, not a prescription. So let me flesh it out, for what it's worth.
If you own a gun (or a lot of guns), fine — you're grandfathered and can keep them until someone pries them from your cold, dead hands. For everyone else, if you want to go hunting, you can rent a rifle or shotgun from the DNR. Want to go target shooting? Rent your Glock from the local police department.
Background check? Photo ID? Tough. These are lethal weapons that should be treated as such, not as something benign as a fishing rod.
Yeah, such an idea is political lunacy, given the clout of the NRA and the timidity of nearly every politician of stature to stand up to that elephantine lobby. But maybe some of them could heed New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who said hours after the shooting that expressing remorse and condolences isn't enough, that the men running for president need to explicitly say what concrete proposals they have for ratcheting down the gun violence that has engulfed this country.
Bloomberg is an unabashed advocate of gun control laws. Maybe he should try Molly's idea, start a nationwide trend. Out of the mouths of babes.
Comments (2)
Hi Bob.
Well it's sweet and thought provoking but I believe I have the right to bare arms and I want to keep that right. I only own hunting guns but I believe in the bases of the constitution plus in light of issues we are facing in this country with the huge disparity between the working class and the Ruling class we need to keep our options opened for we have the right to descend. I didnot ask for Gunatonimo Prison nor the BlackWater Army nor policies which reflect Plutocracy but I think the future seems uncertain and add in the Drone Factor well I just fell safer having rights to my firearms then having to ask a law enforcement officer to decide if I can. Plus the Patriot Acts alined the Polic and Sheriffs Depts together so how will that affect us....I am not a sheep. I have rights to disagree and defend my rights. I also am puzzled by consistent and periodic out breaks of gun violence and of course feel bad but I feel this is the risk we all face in our daily lives and it is really safer today then it was lets say 80 years ago. Things happen which I do not support but giving up anymore of my Rights I draw the line. Thank You for such an enlightening suggestion!
Life is simpler for 10 year olds, bless their hearts. You might ask this bright kid, James Holmes, what he would have used if he didn't have firearms? Maybe the way of Tim McVey or the Sarin gas attacks in the subways of Tokyo? We need to get real. What is the root of such viciousness? Alienation? Disintigration of the family and neighborhood? People not connected to people any longer? Instead of bailing the overflowing bathtub, turn the faucet off first! Deal with the root cause of the problem that creates such human monsters.
Post a comment
Please be civil, brief and relevant.
E-mail addresses are never displayed but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. MPR reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air with attribution. Please read the Terms and Conditions before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to Minnesota Public Radio. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited e-mail and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.



