Commentary
Stimulant drinks will give you energy, but they may also get you a lecture from the dentist
by Hani HamdanHani Hamdan lives in Burnsville and practices dentistry in Lakeville, Minn. He is a contributor and editor of Engagemn.com and a source in MPR's Public Insight Network.
I was watching a Web video the other day when it was interrupted by an ad. The ad started with a problem: people looking tired and sleepy at work. Then it offered the solution: an over-the-counter stimulant that works "faster and better than coffee."
The newest major culprits behind cavities in the patients I see in my dental practice are sports drinks and the so-called "energy drinks," which are designed to provide an optimized concoction of stimulants not strong enough to be called cocaine, and loads of cavity-causing sugar.
Naturally, the sugar part gives my hygienist and me the perfect opportunity to give you a lecture in the dental chair (we lecture nicely). But I also take issue with the idea that the solution to our fatigue and sleepiness at work is a liquid zap to our nervous systems. As study after study shows, what Americans need is more sleep and better sleep. High-efficiency stimulants seem to do the opposite of helping in that arena.
The ad suggests that you can be back to your absolutely normal self after a sip of stimulant slaps your whiney, sleep-deprived brain back to its senses, adding another few hours of normal productivity to your work schedule.
But doctors know that being sleep deprived will alter your sharpness, memory and decision-making abilities no matter how much stimulant you have in your system. The ad's implied promise is misleading, because if your brain needs sleep, it will not function at its best until it gets that one thing: sleep.
The dangers posed by sleep-deprived people driving or operating machinery are well known. Imagine what might happen if truck drivers, for example, cannot detect that they need sleep because an energy drink is masking their symptoms.
Another particularly dangerous way of consuming energy drinks is to mix them with alcoholic beverages, because it causes drunk people to not realize how drunk they are.
The long-term possible effects of sleep deprivation also include weight gain, heart disease, diabetes and depression. Adding an energy drink to this debacle doesn't ring "solution" to me, and it may well come with a set of withdrawal symptoms if you don't get your caffeine fix for the day.
Shortly after I started working full time, I remember, I started to skimp on sleep and make it up on weekends. It would get worse during Minnesota summers, with the short nights. This took a toll on me physically and mentally. I didn't get my health back until I started taking my sleep seriously. For me, that meant allocating and abiding by the number of hours I need every day to sleep in a comfortable bed with no noise or light.
What I needed was sleep. Not an energy drink. And certainly not a lecture from a dentist.
Comments (4)
Thank you for this informative (and lightly humorous) article. I've discussed it with my teenaged son, who would like to drink those energy drinks, but I won't let them in the house. He now agrees that I was right to ban them!
I drink three high caffeine energy drinks per day (280 mg each) and have been doing so for about six years now. My last health report was excellent (I am 47 years old).
I 100% agree. If you need a boost for some out of normal reason, fine us it. But don't use it as an every day/week crutch. Jamey, you sound like a health nut, so of course your usage won't affect you as much as the usual unsuspecting drinker. The much used sport drinks are not good for you either. 20 years ago, my college nutrition science teacher (she specialized in obesity & was a marathon runner) said sports drinks are a sales gimmick and is nothing but glorified kool-aid. Our bodies can only consume so many electrolites at a time and flooding ourselves with them will do no good. You're just adding more sugar to your body. Oh and those unnatural food dyes in those drinks are banded in Europe because they cause ADD, ADHD, Emotional Behavior Disorders, Autism, etc. You are better off drinking unfiltered tap water. It gives you all the electrolites you need. You maybe surprised that it can give you a pick me up feel too.
& pop makes u fat
Tax that crap
Post a comment
Please be civil, brief and relevant.
E-mail addresses are never displayed but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. MPR reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air with attribution. Please read the Terms and Conditions before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to Minnesota Public Radio. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited e-mail and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.
