![]() |
April 10, 2006
RalliesDoes the size of a rally really indicate how the public feels about an issue? Of course the reason I ask is because of the huge rally Sunday in St. Paul. About 30,000 people marched from the St. Paul Cathedral to the Capitol. The principal reason for the march was to oppose the bill passed by the U.S. House which would make it a felony to be in the country illegally and would impose penalties against churches and other charitable groups for helping illegal immigrants. On Saturday a few dozen people rallied on the other side of the issue, supporting, among other things, building a fence along the Mexican border. MPR's Annie Baxter let both sides have their say in her story: Marlene Nelson, of Owatonna, attended an anti-immigration rally at the Capitol on Saturday, which was organized on short notice and drew fewer than 100 people. Nelson's with a group called the Steele County Coalition or Immigration Reduction and she says immigrants, namely Mexican immigrants, can't all expect a helping hand. So because one side turns out 30,000 people and the other side turns out 50, does it mean that there is overwhelming support for one side and almost none for the other. Well, no. It could mean that the one side is better organized, or that it put all its efforts into the rally, or that the stakes just seem higher for that group. The real question is how much heat these rallies and other organizing out on the politicians. And we'll see how that plays out in the next few weeks. For the past month or so I've been putting together a podcast of our political stories every weekday. I did it again today, but there's a technical problem with actually getting it out. So if you're one of the few and proud who listen to that thing you'll have to wait until some of our technical people get in before you can get your daily fix. Update 8:10 a.m. The podcast is there. Posted by Mike Mulcahy at 7:24 AMI would have to say, that in this case, size does matter. The huge crowd that rallied for dignity and respect indicated not only the organizational strength and capacity of the immigrant community but also their deeply held hope to become citizens as well as their finely tuned understanding of what citizenship actually means. The fact that only 50 odd people gathered to promote bigotry and hatred indicates that the hope of the immigrant community might not be misplaced. I wish that some of those hate filled people who rallied against welcoming immigrants into Minnesota could have spent some time at Sunday’s rally. I am certain that the march was the safest and happiest place to be in the metro area. I am quite convinced that only the most hate filled bigot could have maintained opposition to a comprehensive immigration reform with a path to citizenship if they had just attended the rally on Sunday. I wish their cheerleader-in-chief, Governor Pawlenty had attended the rally so that he could have met the people he is so interested in harassing, profiling, and deporting. Perhaps a little human contact would have educated him a bit on the issues.
|