Monday, November 23, 2009
Votetracker
- Home :
- Legislators :
- Issues
Raising and dedicating portion of sales tax to environmental, cultural programs
The Senate bill that would let voters decide this fall whether to raise the state sales tax by a quarter percent. The proceeds are estimated at $191 million a year for 25 years. The money would go to hunting and fishing resources, parks and trails, clean water programs and the arts. Gov. Pawlenty and House Republicans want to dedicate a portion of the existing sales tax to environmental programs. They oppose the inclusion of arts funding in the same constitutional amendment.
More from MPR:
It's a circus in there (03/22/2006)
Senate approves dedicated state money for outdoors, arts (04/03/2006)
Setting aside a sliver of the sales tax (04/11/2006)
On Earth Day's eve, House deals blow to conservation bill (04/21/2006)
House approves referendum for outdoor resources (04/25/2006)
Polinaut:: Environment, culture, and arts, oh my! (04/25/2006)
SORT VOTES BY: Name | District | Party | Vote House approval
April 25, 2006 (SF2734)
After 5 hours of often cantankerous debate, the House approved the bill on a 78-to-55 vote. Committee members will need to compromise on a central point in order to put the bill’s constitutional amendment before the voters: The Senate’s version would raise the sales and use tax rate by three-eighths of 1 percent to provide the dedicated funding; the amended House version would dedicate three-sixteenths of 1 percent of the existing sales and use tax. Other differences: the Senate bill, passed April 3, would dedicate the funding beginning in 2007 and sunset in 2032; the House bill’s dedication would begin in 2009, with no sunset. In addition, the Senate version provides for the creation of a Heritage Enhancement Council and a Clean Water Council. The House version does not, but it does include a prohibition against increasing taxes or fees or imposing new taxes for seven years.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Abeler | Republican | 48B | FOR |
| Ron Abrams | Republican | 43B | AGAINST |
| Bruce Anderson | Republican | 19A | AGAINST |
| Irv Anderson | DFL | 03A | FOR |
| Joe Atkins | DFL | 39B | FOR |
| Michael Beard | Republican | 35A | AGAINST |
| Connie Bernardy | DFL | 51B | FOR |
| Greg Blaine | Republican | 12B | FOR |
| Fran Bradley | Republican | 29B | AGAINST |
| Laura Brod | Republican | 25A | FOR |
| Mark Buesgens | Republican | 35B | AGAINST |
| Lyndon Carlson | DFL | 45B | AGAINST |
| Mike Charron | Republican | 56A | FOR |
| Karen Clark | DFL | 61A | AGAINST |
| Tony Cornish | Republican | 24B | FOR |
| Ray Cox | Republican | 25B | FOR |
| Lloyd Cybart | Republican | 37A | FOR |
| Gregory M. Davids | Republican | 31B | FOR |
| Jim Davnie | DFL | 62A | AGAINST |
| Chris DeLaForest | Republican | 49A | FOR |
| Matt Dean | Republican | 52B | FOR |
| Randy Demmer | Republican | 29A | AGAINST |
| Jerry Dempsey | Republican | 28A | FOR |
| David Dill | DFL | 06A | FOR |
| Denise Dittrich | DFL | 47A | FOR |
| Dan Dorman | Republican | 27A | AGAINST |
| John Dorn | DFL | 23B | FOR |
| Rob Eastlund | Republican | 17A | FOR |
| Kent Eken | DFL | 02A | FOR |
| Keith Ellison | DFL | 58B | AGAINST |
| Tom Emmer | Republican | 19B | AGAINST |
| Matt Entenza | DFL | 64A | FOR |
| Ron Erhardt | Republican | 41A | FOR |
| Sondra Erickson | Republican | 16A | AGAINST |
| Brad Finstad | Republican | 21B | AGAINST |
| Patti Fritz | DFL | 26B | AGAINST |
| Pat Garofalo | Republican | 36B | FOR |
| Paul Gazelka | Republican | 12A | FOR |
| Barbara Goodwin | DFL | 50A | AGAINST |
| Mindy Greiling | DFL | 54A | AGAINST |
| Bob Gunther | Republican | 24A | FOR |
| Tom Hackbarth | Republican | 48A | FOR |
| Rod Hamilton | Republican | 22B | FOR |
| Rick Hansen | DFL | 39A | FOR |
| Alice Hausman | DFL | 66B | AGAINST |
| Larry Haws | DFL | 15B | FOR |
| Bud Heidgerken | Republican | 13A | FOR |
| Debra Hilstrom | DFL | 46B | FOR |
| Bill Hilty | DFL | 08A | AGAINST |
| Mary Liz Holberg | Republican | 36A | FOR |
| Joe Hoppe | Republican | 34B | FOR |
| Frank Hornstein | DFL | 60B | AGAINST |
| Melissa Hortman | DFL | 47B | FOR |
| Larry Hosch | DFL | 14B | FOR |
| Larry Howes | Republican | 04B | FOR |
| Thomas Huntley | DFL | 07A | AGAINST |
| Mike Jaros | DFL | 07B | AGAINST |
| Jeff Johnson | Republican | 43A | FOR |
| Ruth Johnson | DFL | 23A | FOR |
| Sheldon Johnson | DFL | 67B | AGAINST |
| Al Juhnke | DFL | 13B | FOR |
| Phyllis Kahn | DFL | 59B | AGAINST |
| Margaret Anderson Kelliher | DFL | 60A | FOR |
| Karen Klinzing | Republican | 56B | AGAINST |
| Jim Knoblach | Republican | 15A | AGAINST |
| Lyle Koenen | DFL | 20B | FOR |
| Paul Kohls | Republican | 34A | FOR |
| Philip Krinkie | Republican | 53A | FOR |
| Morrie Lanning | Republican | 09A | FOR |
| Dan Larson | DFL | 63B | AGAINST |
| Ron Latz | DFL | 44B | AGAINST |
| Ann Lenczewski | DFL | 40B | AGAINST |
| John Lesch | DFL | 66A | AGAINST |
| Tina Liebling | DFL | 30A | AGAINST |
| Bernard Lieder | DFL | 01B | FOR |
| Leon Lillie | DFL | 55A | AGAINST |
| Diane Loeffler | DFL | 59A | AGAINST |
| Doug Magnus | Republican | 22A | AGAINST |
| Tim Mahoney | DFL | 67A | AGAINST |
| Paul Marquart | DFL | 09B | FOR |
| Denny McNamara | Republican | 57B | FOR |
| Doug Meslow | Republican | 53B | FOR |
| Frank Moe | DFL | 04A | FOR |
| Joe Mullery | DFL | 58A | AGAINST |
| Mary Murphy | DFL | 06B | AGAINST |
| Michael Nelson | DFL | 46A | AGAINST |
| Peter Nelson | Republican | 17B | FOR |
| Scott Newman | Republican | 18A | AGAINST |
| Bud Nornes | Republican | 10A | FOR |
| Mark Olson | Republican | 16B | AGAINST |
| Mary Ellen Otremba | DFL | 11B | FOR |
| Dennis Ozment | Republican | 37B | FOR |
| Erik Paulsen | Republican | 42B | FOR |
| Michael Paymar | DFL | 64B | AGAINST |
| Gene Pelowski, Jr. | DFL | 31A | FOR |
| Maxine Penas | Republican | 01A | FOR |
| Joyce Peppin | Republican | 32A | FOR |
| Aaron Peterson | DFL | 20A | AGAINST |
| Neil W. Peterson | Republican | 41B | AGAINST |
| Sandra Peterson | DFL | 45A | AGAINST |
| Jeanne Poppe | DFL | 27B | FOR |
| Duke Powell | Republican | 40A | FOR |
| Tom Rukavina | DFL | 05A | AGAINST |
| Connie Ruth | Republican | 26A | FOR |
| Maria Ruud | DFL | 42A | FOR |
| Brita Sailer | DFL | 02B | FOR |
| Char Samuelson | Republican | 50B | FOR |
| Bev Scalze | DFL | 54B | FOR |
| Marty Seifert | Republican | 21A | AGAINST |
| Anthony Sertich | DFL | 05B | AGAINST |
| Dan Severson | Republican | 14A | FOR |
| Katie Sieben | DFL | 57A | FOR |
| Steve Simon | DFL | 44A | AGAINST |
| Dean Simpson | Republican | 10B | FOR |
| Nora Slawik | DFL | 55B | AGAINST |
| Steve Smith | Republican | 33A | FOR |
| Judy Soderstrom | Republican | 08B | FOR |
| Loren Solberg | DFL | 03B | FOR |
| Steve Sviggum | Republican | 28B | FOR |
| Barb Sykora | Republican | 33B | FOR |
| Cy Thao | DFL | 65A | AGAINST |
| Paul Thissen | DFL | 63A | AGAINST |
| Kathy Tingelstad | Republican | 49B | FOR |
| Dean Urdahl | Republican | 18B | FOR |
| Ray Vandeveer | Republican | 52A | AGAINST |
| Jean Wagenius | DFL | 62B | FOR |
| Neva Walker | DFL | 61B | AGAINST |
| Lynn Wardlow | Republican | 38B | FOR |
| Andy Welti | DFL | 30B | AGAINST |
| Andrew Westerberg | Republican | 51A | FOR |
| Torrey Westrom | Republican | 11A | FOR |
| Tim Wilkin | Republican | 38A | AGAINST |
| Kurt Zellers | Republican | 32B | FOR |
More from MPR:
Polinaut:: Environment, culture, and arts, oh my! (04/25/2006)
House approves referendum for outdoor resources (04/25/2006)
House Rules and Legislative Administration Committee restores bill to original form
April 20, 2006 (HF1909/SF2734)
Although introduced in 2005 as a "game and fish" bill by Rep. Tom Hackbarth (R-Cedar), it has been amended repeatedly. On April 18, the bill, as approved by the same committee, would have dedicated three-eighths of 1 percent of current sales and use tax receipts to four areas: fish and wildlife; parks, trails and zoos; cleaning up the state’s waters; and arts, humanities, museums and public broadcasting. The committee voted 22-1 to return it to its original intent.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ron Abrams | Republican | 43B | AGAINST |
| Bruce Anderson | Republican | 19A | FOR |
| Connie Bernardy | DFL | 51B | FOR |
| Lyndon Carlson | DFL | 45B | FOR |
| Joe Hoppe | Republican | 34B | FOR |
| Larry Hosch | DFL | 14B | FOR |
| Jeff Johnson | Republican | 43A | FOR |
| Al Juhnke | DFL | 13B | FOR |
| Margaret Anderson Kelliher | DFL | 60A | FOR |
| Paul Kohls | Republican | 34A | FOR |
| Diane Loeffler | DFL | 59A | FOR |
| Doug Magnus | Republican | 22A | FOR |
| Frank Moe | DFL | 04A | FOR |
| Dennis Ozment | Republican | 37B | FOR |
| Erik Paulsen | Republican | 42B | FOR |
| Jeanne Poppe | DFL | 27B | FOR |
| Brita Sailer | DFL | 02B | FOR |
| Char Samuelson | Republican | 50B | FOR |
| Marty Seifert | Republican | 21A | FOR |
| Anthony Sertich | DFL | 05B | FOR |
| Steve Smith | Republican | 33A | FOR |
| Steve Sviggum | Republican | 28B | FOR |
| Kathy Tingelstad | Republican | 49B | FOR |
More from MPR:
On Earth Day's eve, House deals blow to conservation bill (04/21/2006)
Senate approval
April 3, 2006 (SF 2734)
S.F. 2734, sponsored by Sen. Dallas Sams (DFL-Staples), proposes the constitutional amendment and provides the implementing language. If approved, the sales tax will increase by three-eighths of one percent for 25 years. The additional revenue will be allocated 34 percent to improvement, enhancement, and protection of the state's fish, wildlife, habitat, and fish and wildlife tourism; 22 percent to parks, trails, and zoos; 22 percent to protection and restoration of lakes, rivers, streams, wetlands, and groundwater; and 22 percent to the arts, humanities, museums and public broadcasting. The proposed amendment prohibits the Legislature from using the new revenue to supplant existing funding for the recipients, the new dollars are to supplement current general fund spending. S.F. 2734 was granted final passage, 42-22.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ellen R. Anderson | DFL | 66 | FOR |
| Michele M. Bachmann | Republican | 52 | AGAINST |
| Thomas M. Bakk | DFL | 06 | AGAINST |
| William V. Belanger | Republican | 40 | FOR |
| Linda Berglin | DFL | 61 | FOR |
| Don Betzold | DFL | 51 | FOR |
| Terri Bonoff | DFL | 43 | FOR |
| Satveer Chaudhary | DFL | 50 | FOR |
| Tarryl Clark | DFL | 15 | FOR |
| Richard J. Cohen | DFL | 64 | FOR |
| Dick Day | Republican | 26 | AGAINST |
| D. Scott Dibble | DFL | 60 | FOR |
| Steve Dille | Republican | 18 | AGAINST |
| Michelle L. Fischbach | Republican | 14 | AGAINST |
| Leo T. Foley | DFL | 47 | FOR |
| Dennis R. Frederickson | Republican | 21 | FOR |
| Chris Gerlach | Republican | 37 | AGAINST |
| David Hann | Republican | 42 | AGAINST |
| Linda Higgins | DFL | 58 | AGAINST |
| John C. Hottinger | DFL | 23 | AGAINST |
| Dean E. Johnson | DFL | 13 | FOR |
| Michael J. Jungbauer | Republican | 48 | AGAINST |
| Steve Kelley | DFL | 44 | FOR |
| Bob Kierlin | Republican | 31 | AGAINST |
| Sheila M. Kiscaden | DFL | 30 | FOR |
| Amy Koch | Republican | 19 | AGAINST |
| Paul E. Koering | Republican | 12 | FOR |
| Gary W. Kubly | DFL | 20 | FOR |
| Keith Langseth | DFL | 09 | FOR |
| Cal Larson | Republican | 10 | AGAINST |
| Brian LeClair | Republican | 56 | AGAINST |
| Warren Limmer | Republican | 32 | AGAINST |
| Becky Lourey | DFL | 08 | FOR |
| Sharon Marko | DFL | 57 | AGAINST |
| John Marty | DFL | 54 | FOR |
| Mike McGinn | Republican | 38 | AGAINST |
| James P. Metzen | DFL | 39 | FOR |
| Geoff Michel | Republican | 41 | FOR |
| Steve Murphy | DFL | 28 | FOR |
| Thomas M. Neuville | Republican | 25 | AGAINST |
| Sean R. Nienow | Republican | 17 | FOR |
| Gen Olson | Republican | 33 | FOR |
| Julianne E. Ortman | Republican | 34 | AGAINST |
| Sandra L. Pappas | DFL | 65 | FOR |
| Pat Pariseau | Republican | 36 | AGAINST |
| Lawrence J. Pogemiller | DFL | 59 | FOR |
| Yvonne Prettner Solon | DFL | 07 | FOR |
| Jane B. Ranum | DFL | 63 | FOR |
| Mady Reiter | Republican | 53 | AGAINST |
| Ann H. Rest | DFL | 45 | FOR |
| Claire A. Robling | Republican | 35 | AGAINST |
| Julie A. Rosen | Republican | 24 | AGAINST |
| Carrie L. Ruud | Republican | 04 | FOR |
| Dallas C. Sams | DFL | 11 | FOR |
| Tom Saxhaug | DFL | 03 | FOR |
| Linda Scheid | DFL | 46 | FOR |
| David H. Senjem | Republican | 29 | FOR |
| Rod Skoe | DFL | 02 | FOR |
| Dan Sparks | DFL | 27 | FOR |
| LeRoy A. Stumpf | DFL | 01 | FOR |
| David J. Tomassoni | DFL | 05 | FOR |
| Jim Vickerman | DFL | 22 | FOR |
| Betsy L. Wergin | Republican | 16 | FOR |
| Charles W. Wiger | DFL | 55 | FOR |
More from MPR:
Senate approves dedicated state money for outdoors, arts (04/03/2006)
Senate Taxes Committee approval
March 27, 2006 (SF 2734)
H.F. 2734, sponsored by Sen. Dallas Sams (DFL-Staples), creates several funds to disburse the dollars according to a formula set forth in the bill. The bill creates a heritage enhancement fund and specifies that 34 percent of the receipts be deposited in the fund for improvements and protection of the state's fish, wildlife, habitat and fish and wildlife tourism. Further, the bill specifies that 22 percent of the receipts be deposited in the parks and trails fund for parks, trails and zoos, 22 percent of the receipts be deposited in the clean water fund and be used for protection and restoration of the state's lakes, rivers, streams, wetlands and groundwater, and 22 percent be deposited in an arts, humanities, museum and public broadcasting fund to be spent on arts, humanities, history, museums and public broadcasting. The measure also specifies that the dedicated money from the sales tax supplements, but does not replace, traditional sources of funding. It advanced to the Rules Committee on a 7-4 vote
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas M. Bakk | DFL | 06 | AGAINST |
| William V. Belanger | Republican | 40 | FOR |
| Don Betzold | DFL | 51 | FOR |
| Debbie J. Johnson | Republican | 49 | FOR |
| Warren Limmer | Republican | 32 | AGAINST |
| John Marty | DFL | 54 | FOR |
| Mike McGinn | Republican | 38 | AGAINST |
| Julianne E. Ortman | Republican | 34 | AGAINST |
| Lawrence J. Pogemiller | DFL | 59 | FOR |
| Rod Skoe | DFL | 02 | FOR |
| David J. Tomassoni | DFL | 05 | FOR |
March 22, 2006 (HF1909)
A bill that would ask voters to dedicate a portion of the sales tax to environmental projects has become so loaded down with other proposals that even the bill's sponsor says he doesn't recognize it. Supporters of the measure are upset with the changes. It may be a case of loving a bill to death. What started out as a proposal to dedicate one-eighth of 1 percent of the sales tax to the environment now raises the sales tax by three-eighths of a percent. The bill moving through the House now includes funding for the arts and public broadcasting; it lowers the amount of transit funding in another ballot measure; and it includes yet another constitutional amendment that would ban same-sex marriage.
Result: No Action
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Abeler | Republican | 48B | AGAINST |
| Ron Abrams | Republican | 43B | AGAINST |
| Irv Anderson | DFL | 03A | AGAINST |
| Joe Atkins | DFL | 39B | FOR |
| Connie Bernardy | DFL | 51B | FOR |
| Laura Brod | Republican | 25A | FOR |
| Gregory M. Davids | Republican | 31B | FOR |
| Jim Davnie | DFL | 62A | ABSTAINED |
| Chris DeLaForest | Republican | 49A | FOR |
| David Dill | DFL | 06A | FOR |
| Dan Dorman | Republican | 27A | FOR |
| Ron Erhardt | Republican | 41A | ABSTAINED |
| Larry Howes | Republican | 04B | FOR |
| Mike Jaros | DFL | 07B | FOR |
| Jim Knoblach | Republican | 15A | FOR |
| Lyle Koenen | DFL | 20B | FOR |
| Paul Kohls | Republican | 34A | FOR |
| Philip Krinkie | Republican | 53A | FOR |
| Ann Lenczewski | DFL | 40B | FOR |
| John Lesch | DFL | 66A | AGAINST |
| Paul Marquart | DFL | 09B | FOR |
| Joe Mullery | DFL | 58A | AGAINST |
| Peter Nelson | Republican | 17B | FOR |
| Tom Rukavina | DFL | 05A | FOR |
| Katie Sieben | DFL | 57A | AGAINST |
| Dean Simpson | Republican | 10B | FOR |
| Ray Vandeveer | Republican | 52A | FOR |
| Andrew Westerberg | Republican | 51A | AGAINST |
| Kurt Zellers | Republican | 32B | ABSTAINED |
More from MPR:
It's a circus in there (03/22/2006)
Senate Finance Committee approval
March 22, 2006 (HF2734)
S.F. 2734 proposes a constitutional amendment for placement on the November 2006 general election ballot. If the amendment is approved by voters, the state sales tax will rise by three-eighths of one percent, from 6.5 cents to 6.875 cents per dollar. The additional revenue is dedicated to four funds, under the bill. A fund for fish, wildlife and habitat receives 34 percent of the revenue. The other three funds-for parks, trails and zoos; for clean water; and for arts, humanities, museums and public broadcasting-each receive 22 percent of the new revenue. Revenue estimates indicate that the first fund would receive $177.59 million for FY 08-09, while the other three funds would each receive $114.92 million for the biennium. Senators devoted a significant portion of their discussion to language in the proposed constitutional amendment requiring the additional revenue to be used to supplement traditional funding for the natural and cultural resources outlined in the bill. The proposed amendment prohibits the Legislature from using the additional revenue to supplant traditional funding for fish, wildlife, habitat, fish and wildlife tourism, parks, trails, zoos, protecting and restoring waters, and history. Discussion focused primarily on whether the Legislature could reduce funding for the areas when another significant downturn in the economy and state revenues strikes. The bill advances to the Senate Taxes Committee on a 20-2 vote.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linda Berglin | DFL | 61 | FOR |
| Satveer Chaudhary | DFL | 50 | FOR |
| Richard J. Cohen | DFL | 64 | FOR |
| Steve Dille | Republican | 18 | FOR |
| Michelle L. Fischbach | Republican | 14 | FOR |
| Dennis R. Frederickson | Republican | 21 | FOR |
| Chris Gerlach | Republican | 37 | AGAINST |
| John C. Hottinger | DFL | 23 | FOR |
| Bob Kierlin | Republican | 31 | AGAINST |
| Sheila M. Kiscaden | DFL | 30 | FOR |
| Keith Langseth | DFL | 09 | FOR |
| Cal Larson | Republican | 10 | FOR |
| James P. Metzen | DFL | 39 | FOR |
| Steve Murphy | DFL | 28 | FOR |
| Thomas M. Neuville | Republican | 25 | FOR |
| Sean R. Nienow | Republican | 17 | FOR |
| Gen Olson | Republican | 33 | FOR |
| Sandra L. Pappas | DFL | 65 | FOR |
| Pat Pariseau | Republican | 36 | FOR |
| Jane B. Ranum | DFL | 63 | FOR |
| LeRoy A. Stumpf | DFL | 01 | FOR |
| Charles W. Wiger | DFL | 55 | FOR |
March 14, 2006 (HF3269)
HF3269, sponsored by Rep. Dennis Ozment (R-Rosemount), originally included language that would have divided the revenue among habitat preservation, parks and trails, clean water efforts and an arts, humanities, museum and public broadcasting fund. Following discussion about whether inclusion of the latter fund would improve the probability voters would support the amendment, it was removed. If approved this November by voters, the increased tax would be in effect from July 1, 2007, until June 30, 2032.
Result: Passed
Environment and Natural Resources Committee approval
March 10, 2006 (S.F. 2734,)
S.F. 2734, carried by Sen. Dallas Sams (DFL-Staples), places the amendment on the general election ballot this November. If approved, the sales tax increase takes effect July 1, 2007. The additional revenue is allocated 34 percent to fish, wildlife and habitat projects, 22 percent to parks, trails and zoos, 22 percent to clean water projects, and 22 percent to arts, humanities, museums and public broadcasting. Sams said projections indicate $65 million per year would go to the fish, wildlife and habitat area, while $42 million annually would go to each of the other three areas. The constitutional language in the bill prevents the Legislature from using the dedicated revenue to replace traditional funding for cultural and natural resources.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thomas M. Bakk | DFL | 06 | FOR |
| Satveer Chaudhary | DFL | 50 | FOR |
| John C. Hottinger | DFL | 23 | FOR |
| John Marty | DFL | 54 | FOR |
| Sean R. Nienow | Republican | 17 | FOR |
| Pat Pariseau | Republican | 36 | FOR |
| Tom Saxhaug | DFL | 03 | FOR |
| LeRoy A. Stumpf | DFL | 01 | FOR |






