Sunday, November 22, 2009
Votetracker
- Home :
- Legislators :
- Issues
Handgun carry permit law
In 2003 Minnesota lawmakers passed a bill making it easier to get a permit to carry a handgun. They did so by attaching the "concealed carry" legislation to an unrelated House bill, and sending it over to the Senate.
But that process has been found unconstitutional by the courts. So lawmakers worked on repassing legislation in the 2005 session.
More from MPR:
Appeals court upholds ruling striking down gun law (04/12/2005)
Gun bill's fast track suddenly doesn't seem so fast (04/27/2005)
Senate committee carves up handgun permit bill (05/02/2005)
Senate approves bill to restore gun bill struck down by courts (05/13/2005)
House passes handgun permit bill, sends to governor (05/18/2005)
SORT VOTES BY: Name | District | Party | Vote Governor's Desk
May 24, 2005
Result: Signed
House approval of handgun permit bill
May 18, 2005 (SF2259)
The Republican-controlled House voted 86-47 to reinstate the so-called conceal-carry law, which has been overturned by the courts. The 2003 law allowed adults with a clean record, no mental illness and proper training to get a permit to carry a gun.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jim Abeler | Republican | 48B | FOR |
| Bruce Anderson | Republican | 19A | FOR |
| Irv Anderson | DFL | 03A | FOR |
| Joe Atkins | DFL | 39B | FOR |
| Michael Beard | Republican | 35A | FOR |
| Greg Blaine | Republican | 12B | FOR |
| Fran Bradley | Republican | 29B | FOR |
| Laura Brod | Republican | 25A | FOR |
| Mark Buesgens | Republican | 35B | FOR |
| Mike Charron | Republican | 56A | FOR |
| Tony Cornish | Republican | 24B | FOR |
| Lloyd Cybart | Republican | 37A | FOR |
| Gregory M. Davids | Republican | 31B | FOR |
| Chris DeLaForest | Republican | 49A | FOR |
| Matt Dean | Republican | 52B | FOR |
| Randy Demmer | Republican | 29A | FOR |
| Jerry Dempsey | Republican | 28A | FOR |
| David Dill | DFL | 06A | FOR |
| Denise Dittrich | DFL | 47A | FOR |
| Dan Dorman | Republican | 27A | FOR |
| Rob Eastlund | Republican | 17A | FOR |
| Kent Eken | DFL | 02A | FOR |
| Tom Emmer | Republican | 19B | FOR |
| Sondra Erickson | Republican | 16A | FOR |
| Pat Garofalo | Republican | 36B | FOR |
| Paul Gazelka | Republican | 12A | FOR |
| Bob Gunther | Republican | 24A | FOR |
| Tom Hackbarth | Republican | 48A | FOR |
| Rod Hamilton | Republican | 22B | FOR |
| Rick Hansen | DFL | 39A | FOR |
| Bud Heidgerken | Republican | 13A | FOR |
| Mary Liz Holberg | Republican | 36A | FOR |
| Joe Hoppe | Republican | 34B | FOR |
| Larry Hosch | DFL | 14B | FOR |
| Larry Howes | Republican | 04B | FOR |
| Jeff Johnson | Republican | 43A | FOR |
| Al Juhnke | DFL | 13B | FOR |
| Karen Klinzing | Republican | 56B | FOR |
| Jim Knoblach | Republican | 15A | FOR |
| Lyle Koenen | DFL | 20B | FOR |
| Paul Kohls | Republican | 34A | FOR |
| Philip Krinkie | Republican | 53A | FOR |
| Bernard Lieder | DFL | 01B | FOR |
| Leon Lillie | DFL | 55A | FOR |
| Doug Magnus | Republican | 22A | FOR |
| Tim Mahoney | DFL | 67A | FOR |
| Paul Marquart | DFL | 09B | FOR |
| Denny McNamara | Republican | 57B | FOR |
| Doug Meslow | Republican | 53B | FOR |
| Frank Moe | DFL | 04A | FOR |
| Mary Murphy | DFL | 06B | FOR |
| Peter Nelson | Republican | 17B | FOR |
| Scott Newman | Republican | 18A | FOR |
| Bud Nornes | Republican | 10A | FOR |
| Mark Olson | Republican | 16B | FOR |
| Joe Opatz | DFL | 15B | FOR |
| Mary Ellen Otremba | DFL | 11B | FOR |
| Dennis Ozment | Republican | 37B | FOR |
| Erik Paulsen | Republican | 42B | FOR |
| Maxine Penas | Republican | 01A | FOR |
| Joyce Peppin | Republican | 32A | FOR |
| Neil W. Peterson | Republican | 41B | FOR |
| Jeanne Poppe | DFL | 27B | FOR |
| Duke Powell | Republican | 40A | FOR |
| Tom Rukavina | DFL | 05A | FOR |
| Brita Sailer | DFL | 02B | FOR |
| Char Samuelson | Republican | 50B | FOR |
| Marty Seifert | Republican | 21A | FOR |
| Anthony Sertich | DFL | 05B | FOR |
| Dan Severson | Republican | 14A | FOR |
| Dean Simpson | Republican | 10B | FOR |
| Steve Smith | Republican | 33A | FOR |
| Judy Soderstrom | Republican | 08B | FOR |
| Loren Solberg | DFL | 03B | FOR |
| Steve Sviggum | Republican | 28B | FOR |
| Barb Sykora | Republican | 33B | FOR |
| Kathy Tingelstad | Republican | 49B | FOR |
| Dean Urdahl | Republican | 18B | FOR |
| Ray Vandeveer | Republican | 52A | FOR |
| Lynn Wardlow | Republican | 38B | FOR |
| Andy Welti | DFL | 30B | FOR |
| Andrew Westerberg | Republican | 51A | FOR |
| Torrey Westrom | Republican | 11A | FOR |
| Tim Wilkin | Republican | 38A | FOR |
| Kurt Zellers | Republican | 32B | FOR |
| Ron Abrams | Republican | 43B | AGAINST |
| Connie Bernardy | DFL | 51B | AGAINST |
| Lyndon Carlson | DFL | 45B | AGAINST |
| Karen Clark | DFL | 61A | AGAINST |
| Ray Cox | Republican | 25B | AGAINST |
| Jim Davnie | DFL | 62A | AGAINST |
| John Dorn | DFL | 23B | AGAINST |
| Keith Ellison | DFL | 58B | AGAINST |
| Matt Entenza | DFL | 64A | AGAINST |
| Ron Erhardt | Republican | 41A | AGAINST |
| Patti Fritz | DFL | 26B | AGAINST |
| Barbara Goodwin | DFL | 50A | AGAINST |
| Mindy Greiling | DFL | 54A | AGAINST |
| Alice Hausman | DFL | 66B | AGAINST |
| Debra Hilstrom | DFL | 46B | AGAINST |
| Bill Hilty | DFL | 08A | AGAINST |
| Frank Hornstein | DFL | 60B | AGAINST |
| Melissa Hortman | DFL | 47B | AGAINST |
| Thomas Huntley | DFL | 07A | AGAINST |
| Mike Jaros | DFL | 07B | AGAINST |
| Ruth Johnson | DFL | 23A | AGAINST |
| Sheldon Johnson | DFL | 67B | AGAINST |
| Phyllis Kahn | DFL | 59B | AGAINST |
| Margaret Anderson Kelliher | DFL | 60A | AGAINST |
| Morrie Lanning | Republican | 09A | AGAINST |
| Dan Larson | DFL | 63B | AGAINST |
| Ron Latz | DFL | 44B | AGAINST |
| Ann Lenczewski | DFL | 40B | AGAINST |
| John Lesch | DFL | 66A | AGAINST |
| Tina Liebling | DFL | 30A | AGAINST |
| Diane Loeffler | DFL | 59A | AGAINST |
| Carlos Mariani | DFL | 65B | AGAINST |
| Joe Mullery | DFL | 58A | AGAINST |
| Michael Nelson | DFL | 46A | AGAINST |
| Michael Paymar | DFL | 64B | AGAINST |
| Gene Pelowski, Jr. | DFL | 31A | AGAINST |
| Aaron Peterson | DFL | 20A | AGAINST |
| Sandra Peterson | DFL | 45A | AGAINST |
| Connie Ruth | Republican | 26A | AGAINST |
| Maria Ruud | DFL | 42A | AGAINST |
| Bev Scalze | DFL | 54B | AGAINST |
| Katie Sieben | DFL | 57A | AGAINST |
| Steve Simon | DFL | 44A | AGAINST |
| Nora Slawik | DFL | 55B | AGAINST |
| Cy Thao | DFL | 65A | AGAINST |
| Paul Thissen | DFL | 63A | AGAINST |
| Jean Wagenius | DFL | 62B | AGAINST |
| Neva Walker | DFL | 61B | AGAINST |
More from MPR:
House passes handgun permit bill, sends to governor (05/18/2005)
Senate approval of handgun carry bill
May 13, 2005 (SF2259)
After hours of debate the Senate voted 44-21 for the handgun bill, a duplicate of the 2003 act that courts struck down because of the flawed method lawmakers used to pass it. At the time, supporters of the bill attached it to an unrelated measure, robbing opponents of the chance to make changes they sought. Those opponents were able to attach some of those changes to the bill in a Senate committee, but found themselves stymied as supporters of the handgun law stripped them right back out during the Senate floor debate, saying they trampled the freedom of gun owners. The companion bill in the house is HF2424.
Result: Passed
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Michele M. Bachmann | Republican | 52 | FOR |
| Thomas M. Bakk | DFL | 06 | FOR |
| William V. Belanger | Republican | 40 | FOR |
| Dick Day | Republican | 26 | FOR |
| Steve Dille | Republican | 18 | FOR |
| Michelle L. Fischbach | Republican | 14 | FOR |
| Dennis R. Frederickson | Republican | 21 | FOR |
| David Gaither | Republican | 43 | FOR |
| Chris Gerlach | Republican | 37 | FOR |
| Dean E. Johnson | DFL | 13 | FOR |
| Michael J. Jungbauer | Republican | 48 | FOR |
| Bob Kierlin | Republican | 31 | FOR |
| Sheila M. Kiscaden | DFL | 30 | FOR |
| Dave Kleis | Republican | 15 | FOR |
| Paul E. Koering | Republican | 12 | FOR |
| Gary W. Kubly | DFL | 20 | FOR |
| Keith Langseth | DFL | 09 | FOR |
| Cal Larson | Republican | 10 | FOR |
| Brian LeClair | Republican | 56 | FOR |
| Warren Limmer | Republican | 32 | FOR |
| Becky Lourey | DFL | 08 | FOR |
| James P. Metzen | DFL | 39 | FOR |
| Steve Murphy | DFL | 28 | FOR |
| Thomas M. Neuville | Republican | 25 | FOR |
| Sean R. Nienow | Republican | 17 | FOR |
| Gen Olson | Republican | 33 | FOR |
| Julianne E. Ortman | Republican | 34 | FOR |
| Mark Ourada | Republican | 19 | FOR |
| Pat Pariseau | Republican | 36 | FOR |
| Mady Reiter | Republican | 53 | FOR |
| Claire A. Robling | Republican | 35 | FOR |
| Julie A. Rosen | Republican | 24 | FOR |
| Carrie L. Ruud | Republican | 04 | FOR |
| Dallas C. Sams | DFL | 11 | FOR |
| Tom Saxhaug | DFL | 03 | FOR |
| Linda Scheid | DFL | 46 | FOR |
| David H. Senjem | Republican | 29 | FOR |
| Rod Skoe | DFL | 02 | FOR |
| Dan Sparks | DFL | 27 | FOR |
| LeRoy A. Stumpf | DFL | 01 | FOR |
| David J. Tomassoni | DFL | 05 | FOR |
| Jim Vickerman | DFL | 22 | FOR |
| Betsy L. Wergin | Republican | 16 | FOR |
| Charles W. Wiger | DFL | 55 | FOR |
| Ellen R. Anderson | DFL | 66 | AGAINST |
| Linda Berglin | DFL | 61 | AGAINST |
| Don Betzold | DFL | 51 | AGAINST |
| Satveer Chaudhary | DFL | 50 | AGAINST |
| Richard J. Cohen | DFL | 64 | AGAINST |
| D. Scott Dibble | DFL | 60 | AGAINST |
| Leo T. Foley | DFL | 47 | AGAINST |
| Linda Higgins | DFL | 58 | AGAINST |
| John C. Hottinger | DFL | 23 | AGAINST |
| Steve Kelley | DFL | 44 | AGAINST |
| Sharon Marko | DFL | 57 | AGAINST |
| John Marty | DFL | 54 | AGAINST |
| Mike McGinn | Republican | 38 | AGAINST |
| Geoff Michel | Republican | 41 | AGAINST |
| Mee Moua | DFL | 67 | AGAINST |
| Sandra L. Pappas | DFL | 65 | AGAINST |
| Lawrence J. Pogemiller | DFL | 59 | AGAINST |
| Yvonne Prettner Solon | DFL | 07 | AGAINST |
| Jane B. Ranum | DFL | 63 | AGAINST |
| Ann H. Rest | DFL | 45 | AGAINST |
| Wesley J. Skoglund | DFL | 62 | AGAINST |
More from MPR:
Senate approves bill to restore gun bill struck down by courts (05/13/2005)
Senate Crime Prevention Committee
May 2, 2005 (SF2259)
A revised version of Minnesota's handgun permit law survived a key committee vote. The Senate Crime Prevention Committee kept the bill alive by sending it to its next stop without recommendation. The committee also made significant changes to the bill, amending the bill to say that firearms are prohibited from religious buildings unless churches indicate otherwise, and making it a felony to possess a firearm on school property, including day care centers, universities and youth groups such as boys and girls' clubs. The vote reflects the following: A "yes" vote is a vote to send it to the Rules Committee without a recommendation.
Result: No Action
| Legislator | Party | District | Vote |
|---|---|---|---|
| Linda Berglin | DFL | 61 | FOR |
| Don Betzold | DFL | 51 | FOR |
| Leo T. Foley | DFL | 47 | FOR |
| Dave Kleis | Republican | 15 | FOR |
| Mike McGinn | Republican | 38 | FOR |
| Thomas M. Neuville | Republican | 25 | FOR |
| Jane B. Ranum | DFL | 63 | FOR |
| Carrie L. Ruud | Republican | 04 | FOR |
| Wesley J. Skoglund | DFL | 62 | AGAINST |
More from MPR:
Senate committee carves up handgun permit bill (05/02/2005)






