The Daily Circuit

Compare special effects, then and now

by Eric Ringham, Minnesota Public Radio

11:45 AM, March 13, 2013

LISTEN

The debate over Hollywood's reliance on computer-generated images, or CGI, spilled over into The Daily Circuit on Wednesday. Host Kerri Miller stuck to her distaste for them. Stephanie Curtis maintained that they are fine when done well, as in "Titanic," and annoying when taken too far, as in "Oz The Great and Powerful."

Those are handy examples, because in each case we can go back to earlier versions from pre-CGI days and see what was possible with the special effects of the time. Here are clips from "A Night to Remember" (1958) and "The Wizard of Oz" (1939).

Would you rather watch those, or "Titanic" (1997) and "Oz The Great and Powerful" (2013)?

comments powered by Disqus
Listen Now

MPR News Radio

Hourly Newscast

The Daily Circuit Blog

Economy, Business & Jobs:

Op-ed pick: The Senate’s guest worker program will provide a flexible workforce

"The size of the guest-worker program is designed to adjust automatically in response to changing U.S. labor needs, growing in good years when the economy needs more foreign workers and shrinking when more Americans are out of work."

News & Trends:

3 things to buy at the farmers market this weekend

After we taped the Friday Roundtable, I asked the panelists what we should pick up at the farmer’s market this weekend. Stephanie Meyer recommends morels. Amy Thielen says to buy dandelion greens if you can find them. Dara Moskowitz Grumdahl’s a fan of rhubarb: Here’s what you can do with rhubarb. I like to cook…