So, my friends, what were we thinking? Did we really think that extending health care coverage to all Americans would be easy? Did we really believe that those who reap g'zillions of bucks from our "health" (read "sick") care system were going to give it all up without a fight?
Of course those who benefit from the status quo are attacking the public option. Of course they are falsely claiming that Medicare reimbursement for end-of-life discussions are "death panels." Of course they are disrupting town hall forums -- some even carrying firearms. It's not an element of reform they oppose; it's reform itself.
The special interests and protectors of the status quo acted worse when America was on the brink of passing civil rights and voting rights legislation. They spread lies and fear when America was contemplating women's suffrage, too.
Maybe it's we, and not opponents of reform, who have failed to grasp the magnitude of this moment. We are on the verge of bringing about health care reform 60 years in waiting. Yes, we're going to have to fight for it. I worry that a little rough stuff has discouraged some progressives.
As Frederick Douglass famously said, "Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and never will." It's easy to figure out who the "power" is. The 10 largest health insurers took in $13 billion in 2007 with CEOs earning an average $12 million a year, according to Health Care for America Now.
I have been a little concerned about some Democratic leaders who appear to be dancing away from the public option. But momentary wavering in leadership has provoked expressions of clarity from the people.
Sixty progressives in Congress have roared back in favor of the public option, declaring their unwavering support in a letter to the White House. Thousands of people are raising their voices for the public option around America.
Everyone has someone in their family who has been hurt by not having health care. Now is the time to speak up for every denial because of a pre-existing condition, every forgone procedure, and everyone facing bankruptcy due to medical debt.
We are relearning a valuable lesson. The ones who want to conserve the status quo will accept no compromises. Nothing. Jettisoning the public option won't bring forth a bipartisan bill.
I appreciate U.S. Sen. Richard Shelby's candor. He said that defeating health care reform would benefit Republicans politically. Sen. Jon Kyl, R-Ariz., told reporters that he stands opposed even to health care co-ops.
Rush Limbaugh had this to say: "Co-op? Why don't they just call them communes?" Sen. Jim DeMint said defeating health care would be Obama's "Waterloo."
So, good. No more wasting time. Now, we need a new message: Reconciliation. With a reconciliation vote, you don't need 60 votes to pass a health care bill through the U.S. Senate, but rather a majority vote of 51. Given the intransigence of the opponents, reformers must begin a drumbeat for a reconciliation vote for health care.
We have the power to start that drumbeat. Call your representatives. Post it on Facebook. Twitter for health care. Bring it up in casual conversations. Talk to the clerk who sells you your groceries. Call your mom, call your broker. Go to your church, synagogue or mosque, and pray for the public option.
----
Keith Ellison, D-Minn., represents Minnesota's 5th Congressional District in the U.S. House of Representatives. This article first appeared in the Huffington Post.
Thank you, Keith. I have yet to hear opponents of serious reform answer the most basic question: "Should anyone go without health care?" Unless the answer is "Yes" all parties should be working toward full coverage for all. But the moral question - in fact, it's a spiritual question - isn't driving the debate. It's being driven by vested special interests whose best weapons are demogogic labels that paint "government" as "the State", an enemy of thbe people instead of the instrument OF the people. Power, as you say, never surrenders, nor does it engage in rational discussion. Male privilege and white privilege were not surrendered and women's rights and civil rights were not given. They were taken by the people. Universal health will be the same. Thanks for your clarity.
Well thought out and well written. To the points of what needs to be addressed and who to address it to. Thnak you for sanity on the issues. Just can's figure out WHY people would NEED to come to the various town halls with guns and such hatred towarad a man that is our elected PRES. What is missing here? Is it some deep yet unresolved racial issues? It think that is in that scenario.
i'm 80 yr old vet under va care
i'm very happy with my gov run health
care.my wife is happy with medicare
which is gov run
what scares me is the big insurance co
and drug cos. we need gov op......
We must have the public option.My husband has multiple problems and we don't want medicaid.
We would rather pay.I appreciate what MR. Obama is doing and will vote for him again.
Keith, thanks for the passion and clarity! I agree. Here are some things that could save a lot of $$: generic insulin, incorporating Oriental Medicine into healthcare, preventing the meat/dairy/food processing industry from influencing medical school curriculum, and from influencing the FDA, etc. Disallowing regulators from going directly to industry and industry lobbyists and others from going directly into regulatory and other government positions... The list goes on and on.
Please be civil, brief and relevant.
E-mail addresses are never displayed but they are required to confirm your comments. All comments are moderated. MPR reserves the right to edit any comments on this site and to read them on the air with attribution. Please read the Comment Guidelines before posting.
You must be 13 or over to submit information to Minnesota Public Radio. The information entered into this form will not be used to send unsolicited e-mail and will not be sold to a third party. For more information see Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.