Today's Question Category Archive: Culture

What living writer might still be read 200 years from now?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 7, 2012 by Eric Ringham (25 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Today is the 200th birthday of Charles Dickens, an English author whose works are read and celebrated to this day. Today's Question: What living writer might still be read 200 years from now?

Comment on this post

How do you see the role of satire in our political discourse?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 20, 2012 by Eric Ringham (35 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

The Comedy Central satirists Jon Stewart and Stephen Colbert are making news in this political season. Stewart has a super PAC, and Colbert is mimicking a run for office. Today's Question: How do you see the role of satire in our political discourse?

Comment on this post

Where do you stand on the Stop Online Piracy Act?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 18, 2012 by Eric Ringham (35 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy, Science/Technology

Wikipedia is going dark today to protest the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). Google and other big Internet companies also oppose the legislation, which would compel service providers to block access to overseas websites that violate U.S. copyright laws. Today's Question: Where do you stand on the Stop Online Piracy Act?

Comment on this post

What do you intend to do differently in 2012?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 2, 2012 by Eric Ringham (16 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Now that it's a new year, many people will be trying to make new habits or break old ones. Today's Question: What do you intend to do differently in 2012?

Comment on this post

What's your New Year's resolution for Minnesota?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 30, 2011 by Eric Ringham (36 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

Some people make resolutions for themselves at New Year's, but we'd like to think bigger. Today's Question: What's your New Year's resolution for Minnesota?

Comment on this post

In six words, how would you describe 2011?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 29, 2011 by Eric Ringham (85 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

We're just two days from the end of 2011. Today's Question: In six words, how would you describe 2011?

(Inspired by SMITH Magazine's Six-Word Memoir project and book series .)

Comment on this post

What could arts organizations do better to get you in the door?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 7, 2011 by Eric Ringham (33 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

Some prominent Twin Cities arts organizations are suffering persistent fiscal problems -- the St. Paul Chamber Orchestra, the Minnesota Orchestra and Penumbra Theatre, to name three. Today's Question: What could arts organizations do better to get you in the door?

Comment on this post

When is street art art, and when is it vandalism?

Posted at 5:00 AM on November 18, 2011 by Eric Ringham (40 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

A story on MPR News today describes a young artist who stopped doing graffiti after repeated run-ins with the law. Now he uses yarn to create a different kind of street art that is less likely to be regarded as vandalism. Today's Question: When is street art art, and when is it vandalism?

Comment on this post

Does it matter if there is no NBA season this year?

Posted at 5:00 AM on November 15, 2011 by Eric Ringham (33 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Players have rejected the NBA's latest contract offer, raising the prospect that there will be no pro basketball games this year. Today's Question: Does it matter if there is no NBA season this year?

Comment on this post

For you or for people you know, has military service been a positive experience?

Posted at 5:00 AM on November 11, 2011 by Eric Ringham (26 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Security

Today is Veteran's Day, when we honor those who have served in our country's military. Today's Question: For you or for people you know, has military service been a positive experience?

Comment on this post

Are professional sports teams a part of Minnesota's cultural heritage?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 28, 2011 by Eric Ringham (106 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy, Politics/Government

Some state leaders have said they are open to the idea of using money from the state's Legacy funds to help finance a new football stadium. The money would come from the Arts and Cultural Heritage Fund generated by a sales tax that Minnesota voters approved in 2008. (MPR is among hundreds of organizations that receive money from the fund.) Today's Question: Are professional sports teams a part of Minnesota's cultural heritage?

Comment on this post

Do you expect a Vikings deal to get done, and should it?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 18, 2011 by Eric Ringham (63 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

Gov. Mark Dayton on has set a Nov. 23 deadline for the Legislature to pass a Vikings stadium plan, but has not yet endorsed a specific proposal. Today's Question: Do you expect a Vikings deal to get done, and should it?

Comment on this post

During your lifetime, what year has felt most like a turning point for the country?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 14, 2011 by Eric Ringham (50 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

A new exhibit at the Minnesota History Center focuses on the year 1968, a time of extreme turmoil and profound change in American society. Today's Question: During your lifetime, what year has felt most like a turning point for the country?

Comment on this post

How much do you care about keeping a connection to your ancestral homeland?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 11, 2011 by Eric Ringham (40 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, International affairs

More than 16 percent of the Minnesota population claims Norwegian ancestry, which may help explain interest in the current visit by the king and queen of Norway. Today's Question: How much do you care about keeping a connection to your ancestral homeland?

Comment on this post

What do you think of SlutWalk?

Posted at 5:00 AM on September 30, 2011 by Eric Ringham (48 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Race/Gender, Security

Hundreds of people have signed up for SlutWalk Minneapolis, a march to protest the view that women bring sexual assault upon themselves. Some critics think the march and its name work against women's interests. Today's Question: What do you think of SlutWalk?

Comment on this post

Is using Cheech and Chong to promote brownies genius, folly or something else?

Posted at 5:00 AM on September 23, 2011 by Eric Ringham (30 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

General Mills has hired the stoner comedy duo Cheech and Chong to help promote a line of brownies. A video invites viewers to "get high ... on fiber." Today's Question: Is using Cheech and Chong to promote brownies genius, folly or something else?

Comment on this post

How accepting is the culture of your workplace toward openly gay and lesbian employees?

Posted at 5:00 AM on September 19, 2011 by Eric Ringham (31 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

Tuesday marks the end of the Don't Ask, Don't Tell policy that forced gays and lesbians in the military to keep their sexuality a secret. Today's Question: How accepting is the culture of your workplace toward openly gay and lesbian employees?

Comment on this post

Should the State Fair prohibit smoking on the fairgrounds?

Posted at 5:00 AM on September 1, 2011 by Eric Ringham (67 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Health

Although the Minnesota State Fair prohibits smoking in public buildings and in the seating areas of entertainment venues, fairgoers encounter lots of cigarette smoke. Today's Question: Should the State Fair prohibit smoking on the fairgrounds?

Comment on this post

What do you like best about the State Fair?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 25, 2011 by Eric Ringham (17 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

It's opening day of the Minnesota State Fair, the second-largest state fair in the country. Between now and Labor Day, an expected crowd of 1.7 million people will visit. Today's Question: What do you like best about the State Fair?

Comment on this post

Should Minnesota suspend moose hunting?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 18, 2011 by Eric Ringham (39 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Environment/Energy

Minnesota's moose population is in sharp decline, but the DNR says hunting is not the reason. State officials would like to ban the feeding of deer, a practice that concentrates deer and exposes moose to disease. Today's Question: Should Minnesota suspend moose hunting?

Comment on this post

Is the University of North Dakota doing the right thing in retiring the Fighting Sioux nickname?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 16, 2011 by Eric Ringham (50 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education, Race/Gender

Higher education officials have voted to retire the University of North Dakota's Fighting Sioux nickname by the end of the year, and lawmakers are expected to repeal a law requiring the school to keep it. Today's Question: Is the University of North Dakota doing the right thing in retiring the Fighting Sioux nickname?

Comment on this post

Do you find Obama or Boehner more persuasive?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 26, 2011 by Eric Ringham (97 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Science/Technology

President Obama and House Speaker John Boehner addressed the nation last night to give their different views of the debt-ceiling impasse. Today's Question: Do you find Obama or Boehner more persuasive?

Comment on this post

What was the best rock concert you ever attended?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 22, 2011 by Eric Ringham (130 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

This weekend marks the first big outdoor stadium concert the Twin Cities has seen in decades, when U2 plays TCF Stadium at the University of Minnesota. Today's Question:
What was the best rock concert you ever attended?

Comment on this post

Would you fish without a license?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 14, 2011 by Eric Ringham (50 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Environment/Energy, Politics/Government, Religion/Ethics

It's the height of fishing season, but there's no way to buy a license during the state shutdown. Though the DNR says no, some local authorities have said it's probably OK to fish now and get a license later. Today's Question: Would you fish without a license?

Comment on this post

Do strong performances by American soccer teams capture your interest?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 13, 2011 by Eric Ringham (35 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Though Americans lack the soccer traditions of other countries, the U.S. team is playing well in the Women's World Cup. The U.S. defeated France today in the semifinals. Today's Question: Do strong performances by American soccer teams capture your interest?

Comment on this post

How will you celebrate the Fourth of July?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 4, 2011 by Eric Ringham (18 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

John Adams thought that Independence Day ought to be observed with "acts of devotion to God" and "with pomp and parade, with shows, games, sports, guns, bells, bonfires, and illuminations." Today's Question: How will you celebrate the Fourth of July?

Comment on this post

Should books cater to a taste for violence, if that's what teens want to read?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 20, 2011 by Eric Ringham (24 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

Today's "Midmorning" looks at a controversy surrounding fiction for young adults. Critics say too much of it is dark, disturbing and violent. Today's Question: Should books cater to a taste for violence, if that's what teens want to read?

Comment on this post

Should we change place names that don't fit with modern values?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 16, 2011 by Eric Ringham (42 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Religion/Ethics

A Minneapolis history buff is campaigning to change the name of Lake Calhoun because its namesake, Vice President John Calhoun, was a proponent of slavery. Today's Question: Should we change place names that don't fit with modern values?

Comment on this post

Would you rather protect kids too much, or too little?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 14, 2011 by Eric Ringham (35 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

A psychologist appearing on Midmorning today argues that parents try too hard to shield their children from misfortune. She says that overprotected children are underprepared for life. Today's Question: Would you rather protect kids too much, or too little?

Comment on this post

Is your community bike-friendly?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 9, 2011 by Eric Ringham (31 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Today is Bike Walk to Work Day in the Twin Cities, part of Minnesota Bike Walk Week. A proclamation from the governor notes that Minneapolis has been named the Number One bike-friendly city in the nation. Today's Question: Is your community bike-friendly?

Comment on this post

What message would you give the class of 2011, if you had only six words to say it?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 2, 2011 by Eric Ringham (164 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

It's graduation season. Commencement speakers are doing their best to inspire graduates, but some of their speeches seem a little long. Today's Question: What message would you give the class of 2011, if you had only six words to say it?

(Inspired by SMITH Magazine's Six-Word Memoir project and book series .)

Comment on this post

How big a role do ticket prices play in your choice of entertainment options?

Posted at 5:00 AM on May 25, 2011 by Eric Ringham (39 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

Mixed Blood Theater in Minneapolis has announced that it will stop charging for admission to its shows. Potential patrons had identified ticket prices as a barrier. Today's Question: How big a role do ticket prices play in your choice of entertainment options?

Comment on this post

Why are we so interested in predictions about the end of the world?

Posted at 5:00 AM on May 20, 2011 by Eric Ringham (49 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Religion/Ethics

Predictions about the end of the world come and go. The one getting all the attention just now says the end will begin at 6 p.m. this Saturday. Today's Question: Why are we so interested in predictions about the end of the world?

Comment on this post

Do the lives of the royals interest you?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 28, 2011 by Eric Ringham (55 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, International affairs, Politics/Government

There is speculation that the wedding of Britain's Prince William and Kate Middleton could draw an even bigger worldwide audience than that of William's parents in 1981. Today's Question: Do the lives of the royals interest you?

Comment on this post

What piece of music stirs emotions in you?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 25, 2011 by Eric Ringham (51 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

A discussion on today's Midmorning looks at the ways music can trigger memories and emotional responses for the listener. We'd like to hear about music that you find especially expressive. Today's Question: What piece of music stirs emotions in you?

Comment on this post

What Minnesotans would you rank among the world's most influential people?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 22, 2011 by Eric Ringham (38 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Time Magazine has included Rep. Michele Bachmann on its list of the 100 most influential people in the world. Today's Question: What Minnesotans would you rank among the world's most influential people?

Comment on this post

What single book was most influential in your life?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 18, 2011 by Eric Ringham (75 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

This weekend saw the premiere of the film treatment of "Atlas Shrugged," a book that many readers say was influential in their lives. Today's Question: What single book was most influential in your life?

Comment on this post

What place has closed that you really miss?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 1, 2011 by Eric Ringham (123 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Porky's drive-in restaurant, a fixture in St. Paul since 1953, will close on Sunday. Customers say they will miss not only the food but the memories and way of life that Porky's represents. Today's Question: What place has closed that you really miss?

Comment on this post

Should college athletes be paid?

Posted at 5:00 AM on March 29, 2011 by Eric Ringham (43 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

As the end of March Madness draws near, TV ratings for the tournament series are the highest they've been in years. The NCAA tournament generates billions of dollars in commerce, though not for the players themselves. Today's Question: Should college athletes be paid?

Update: We posed this question to sources in our Public Insight Network. Below is a collection of some of the responses we received. Press the play button to get started.

Comment on this post

What movie would you consider the best picture of 2010, and why?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 25, 2011 by Eric Ringham (17 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Ten films are in contention to be named Best Picture Sunday night at the 83rd Academy Awards. Today's Question: What movie would you consider the best picture of 2010, and why?

Comment on this post

Who is your favorite U.S. president of all time?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 21, 2011 by Eric Ringham (28 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

Americans celebrate the third Monday in February as President's Day, continuing a tradition that began as an observance of George Washington's birthday. Today's Question: Who is your favorite U.S. president of all time?

Comment on this post

Is it time to allow Minnesotans to buy liquor on Sundays?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 4, 2011 by Jon Gordon (70 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy, Religion/Ethics

Several cash-strapped states, including Minnesota, are once again considering proposals to end their bans on store-based alcohol sales on Sundays as a way to generate revenue. Today's Question: Is it time to allow Minnesotans to buy liquor on Sundays?

Comment on this post

What would you like to see happen with the Metrodome?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 21, 2011 by Eric Ringham (34 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Metrodome is almost 30 years old and may need a whole new roof. Authorities aren't sure how long it will take to fix. Today's Question: What would you like to see happen with the Metrodome?

Comment on this post

How close have we come to realizing Martin Luther King's dream?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 17, 2011 by Eric Ringham (16 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Race/Gender

The Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. spoke of his dream that one day people would be judged not by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character. Today's Question: How close have we come to realizing Martin Luther King's dream?

Comment on this post

Should an editor change a classic novel to keep from offending modern readers?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 5, 2011 by Eric Ringham (96 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Race/Gender

A Mark Twain scholar plans to release a new edition of "The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn" without the N word. Today's Question: Should an editor change a classic novel to keep from offending modern readers?

Comment on this post

What do you intend to do differently in the new year?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 31, 2010 by Eric Ringham (6 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Tomorrow is the first day of 2011. Today's Question: What do you intend to do differently in the new year?

Comment on this post

What was the local arts highlight of 2010?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 30, 2010 by Eric Ringham (16 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Minnesota arts scene produces hundreds of concerts, shows, exhibits and performances every year. Today's Question: What was the local arts highlight of 2010?

Comment on this post

What would you consider the top news story of 2010?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 29, 2010 by Eric Ringham (14 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Toward the end of December, many media organizations look back over the top news stories of the past year. Today's Question: What would you consider the top news story of 2010?

Comment on this post

What's your approach to gift-giving at the holidays?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 24, 2010 by Eric Ringham (8 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy, Religion/Ethics

Some people try to shop according to their values at the holidays, purchasing gifts that are sustainable or charitable in some way. Today's Question: What's your approach to gift-giving at the holidays?

Comment on this post

Would you expect the computer to win at 'Jeopardy,' or one of the humans?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 22, 2010 by Eric Ringham (9 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Science/Technology

In an important test of artificial intelligence, an IBM computer will compete with star contestants on "Jeopardy" this February. Today's Question: Would you expect the computer to win, or one of the humans?

Comment on this post

At the holidays, who do you tip, and why, and how much?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 17, 2010 by Eric Ringham (20 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

A common holiday custom is to give tips to those who provide services throughout the year. Today's Question: At the holidays, who do you tip, and why, and how much?

Comment on this post

Who would be your pick for Minnesotan of the year?

Posted at 5:00 AM on December 16, 2010 by Eric Ringham (22 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Time Magazine announced its choice Wednesday for Person of the Year: Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. Today's Question: Who would be your pick for Minnesotan of the year?

Comment on this post

What Thanksgiving dish is special to your family?

Posted at 5:00 AM on November 24, 2010 by Eric Ringham (16 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Historical documents suggest that the feast in 1621 which inspired traditional Thanksgiving meals in America included poultry, venison, fish and corn. Today's Question: What Thanksgiving dish is special to your family?

Comment on this post

How big a role does the anchor play in your choice of a newscast to watch?

Posted at 5:00 AM on November 22, 2010 by Eric Ringham (32 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Tonight is Don Shelby's final broadcast as anchor of the 10 p.m. news on WCCO-TV. Today's Question: How big a role does the anchor play in your choice of a newscast to watch?

Comment on this post

Do you think there's a political bias in public radio programming?

Posted at 5:00 AM on November 11, 2010 by Eric Ringham (115 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

In recent weeks, various critics have suggested that they see a political bias in public radio. Today's Question: Do you think there's a political bias in public radio programming?

Comment on this post

How important is it for the state's flagship university to have winning sports teams?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 19, 2010 by Eric Ringham (23 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

The University of Minnesota is looking for a new football coach after a disappointing start to the 2010 season and a long record of lackluster performances. Today's Question: How important is it for the state's flagship university to have winning sports teams?

Comment on this post

When sports figures perform poorly, on or off the field, how does it affect you?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 15, 2010 by Eric Ringham (21 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Twins, the Vikings and the Gophers have all disappointed their fans lately, and revelations about Brett Favre's personal life have tarnished his image. Today's Question:
When sports figures perform poorly, on or off the field, how does it affect you?

Comment on this post

For good or ill, how has the Twins ballpark affected the community?

Posted at 5:00 AM on October 1, 2010 by Eric Ringham (18 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Target Field is setting attendance records as it concludes its inaugural regular season this weekend. Today's Question: For good or ill, how has the Twins ballpark affected the community?

Comment on this post

What's the best or worst thing that's ever happened to you at the State Fair?

Posted at 5:00 AM on September 3, 2010 by Eric Ringham (16 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

It's MPR Day at the State Fair, which is heading into the final weekend of its 2010 season. Today's Question: What's the best or worst thing that's ever happened to you at the State Fair?

Comment on this post

What can the State Fair teach visitors about Minnesota?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 26, 2010 by Eric Ringham (22 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Minnesota State Fair opens today, and among the expected visitors this year are journalists from several foreign countries. Today's Question: What can the State Fair teach visitors about Minnesota?

Comment on this post

What's your favorite Beatles song?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 20, 2010 by Eric Ringham (68 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

This weekend is the 45th anniversary of the time the Beatles came to town. Today's Question: What's your favorite Beatles song?

Comment on this post

What's your favorite cultural event of the summer?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 6, 2010 by Eric Ringham (19 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Minnesota Fringe Festival has opened; the Loring Park Art festival is this weekend; the Minnesota State Fair is coming up. Today's Question: What's your favorite cultural event of the summer?

Comment on this post

Should a judge be able to overrule a decision by voters?

Posted at 5:00 AM on August 5, 2010 by Eric Ringham (78 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

The federal judge who overturned a same-sex marriage ban approved by California voters ruled that gays and lesbians have a constitutional right to marry. Today's Question: Should a judge be able to overrule a decision by voters?

Comment on this post

How have you resolved a conflict with a neighbor?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 28, 2010 by Eric Ringham (19 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Today's Midmorning looks at neighbors and what happens when problems arise between them. Today's Question: How have you resolved a conflict with a neighbor?

Comment on this post

Is owning a cabin part of your Minnesota dream?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 22, 2010 by Eric Ringham (45 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

It's summer in Minnesota, which means that people who have lake cabins are there, headed there or just back from there. Today's Question: Is owning a cabin part of your Minnesota dream?

Comment on this post

When is profanity acceptable?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 15, 2010 by Eric Ringham (28 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

An appeals court has struck down the FCC's indecency policy, saying its harsh ban on expletives could have a chilling effect on free speech. Today's Question: When is profanity acceptable?

Comment on this post

What song would you like to see as our national anthem?

Posted at 5:00 AM on July 5, 2010 by Eric Ringham (17 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

Almost 80 years after Congress declared it our national anthem, "The Star-Spangled Banner" remains a controversial choice. Today's Question: What song would you like to see as our national anthem?

Comment on this post

How does having children change your outlook?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 30, 2010 by Eric Ringham (18 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Health, Race/Gender

A new study finds that the percentage of women who never have children has doubled since the 1970s. Today's Question: How does having children change your outlook?

Comment on this post

What advice would you give a young person who plans to get a tattoo?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 29, 2010 by Eric Ringham (28 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Health

As of Thursday, state law will bar anyone under age 18 from getting a tattoo, even with a parent's permission. Today's Question: What advice would you give a young person who plans to get a tattoo?

Comment on this post

In honor of "Wait Wait," write a news limerick

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 25, 2010 by Eric Ringham (25 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

One year since the Question's inaugural,
With thousands of answers (we've logged them all),
Let's show our esprit
For "Wait Wait ... Don't Tell Me!"
Today, we want five lines of doggerel.

Peter Sagal and Carl Kasell are doing their show from Minnesota this week. In their honor, Today's Question invites you to post a news limerick. But remember ... keep it clean.

Comment on this post

What does the World Cup mean to you?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 11, 2010 by Eric Ringham (18 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, International affairs

Beginning today, hundreds of millions of people around the globe will be watching the World Cup soccer tournament. Today's Question: What does the World Cup mean to you?

Comment on this post

Does summer vacation still serve a useful purpose?

Posted at 5:00 AM on June 7, 2010 by Eric Ringham (28 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

The end of the traditional academic year brings summer vacation, but some school districts are moving toward year-round classes. Today's Question: Does summer vacation still serve a useful purpose?

Comment on this post

How should America memorialize the war in Iraq and Afghanistan?

Posted at 5:00 AM on May 31, 2010 by Eric Ringham (7 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, International affairs

Visitors to Washington can see a variety of war memorials, covering conflicts of varying size and duration. Today's Question: How should America memorialize the war in Iraq and Afghanistan?

Comment on this post

What does the fishing opener mean to your family?

Posted at 5:00 AM on May 14, 2010 by Eric Ringham (17 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Tomorrow's fishing opener is a big event in Minnesota, a state that sells more fishing licenses per capita than any other. Today's Question: What does the fishing opener mean to your family?

Comment on this post

What's your message for the Class of 2010?

Posted at 5:00 AM on May 13, 2010 by Eric Ringham (22 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

Jon Stewart said, "Love what you do. Get good at it." Winston Churchill said, "Never give in. Never, never, never, never." It's commencement season, and you or someone you know will soon be listening to a speech. Today's Question: What's your message for the Class of 2010?

Comment on this post

What grand adventure do you dream about?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 26, 2010 by Eric Ringham (30 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

A Minnesota couple is setting out to travel all the way around Lake Superior on foot. Today's Question: What grand adventure do you dream about?

Comment on this post

Who is the modern-day Mark Twain?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 13, 2010 by Eric Ringham (39 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Next week marks the hundredth anniversary of the death of the beloved American writer and humorist Mark Twain. Today's Question: Who is the modern-day Mark Twain?

Comment on this post

Now that Target Field is built, are you glad we have it?

Posted at 5:00 AM on April 12, 2010 by Eric Ringham (72 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

After years of controversy, the Minnesota Twins finally open their home season today in a new outdoor ballpark. Today's Question: Now that Target Field is built, are you glad we have it?

Comment on this post

What relic, from all of history, would you most like to see?

Posted at 5:00 AM on March 15, 2010 by Eric Ringham (26 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Science Museum of Minnesota opened its exhibit of the Dead Sea Scrolls over the weekend. Other recent exhibits have featured artifacts from the Titanic and Pompeii. Today's Question: What relic, from all of history, would you most like to see?

Comment on this post

Have recent events changed the way you think about cars?

Posted at 5:00 AM on March 8, 2010 by Eric Ringham (10 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Transportation

The Twin Cities Auto Show opened last weekend after a year that rocked the car industry with government takeovers, safety recalls and volatile gas prices. Today's Question: Have recent events changed the way you think about cars?

Comment on this post

What movie should win Best Picture?

Posted at 5:00 AM on March 5, 2010 by Eric Ringham (25 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

One of the films nominated for a Best Picture Oscar is "Avatar," the largest-grossing movie in history. But its popularity doesn't mean it will win. Today's Question: What movie should win Best Picture?

Comment on this post

How has social networking changed your life?

Posted at 5:00 AM on March 3, 2010 by Eric Ringham (24 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Science/Technology

Facebook was born six years ago. It now has more than 400 million active users, a population that would make it the third largest country on Earth. Today's Question: How has social networking changed your life?

Comment on this post

Does it matter who in your family makes the most money?

Posted at 7:37 AM on March 2, 2010 by Steve Mullis (25 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

For the first time in history, women now constitute more than half the American workforce. In many households women are the chief breadwinner, or the only breadwinner. Today's Question: Does it matter who in your family makes the most money?

Comment on this post

Would you rather watch the Olympics live during the day, or in the evening on tape?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 22, 2010 by Eric Ringham (12 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, International affairs

In an effort to boost its prime time ratings, NBC is limiting web and cable coverage of live events at the Olympics. As a result, fans have to watch some of their favorite events on tape delay, hours after they conclude. Today's Question: Would you rather watch the Olympics live during the day, or in the evening on tape?

Comment on this post

What makes someone a Minnesotan?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 18, 2010 by Eric Ringham (13 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The American skier Lindsey Vonn won a gold medal yesterday in the women's downhill in Vancouver. Minnesotans claim her as one of their own because she was born in St. Paul. But Vonn's Team USA profile does not mention Minnesota, saying only that her family moved to Vail when she was 12. Today's Question: What makes someone a Minnesotan?

Comment on this post

Did any of the Super Bowl commercials tempt you to buy or try their product?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 8, 2010 by Eric Ringham (26 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The commercials that aired during yesterday's Super Bowl cost a minimum of $2.5 million for a 30-second spot. That means advertisers paid more than $83,000 per second to get your attention. Today's Question: Did any of the Super Bowl commercials tempt you to buy or try their product?

Comment on this post

Why do you choose to live in Minnesota?

Posted at 5:00 AM on February 3, 2010 by Eric Ringham (60 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

On Tuesday, the legendary groundhog saw his shadow, which is supposed to predict that winter will last six more weeks. But in Minnesota, it's a safe bet that winter will be interminable. Today's Question: Why do you choose to live in Minnesota?

Comment on this post

What book changed your life?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 29, 2010 by Anna Weggel (78 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Yesterday famed author J.D. Salinger died at the age of 91. His books, most notably "The Catcher in the Rye", have been formative reading experiences for generations of young people. Today's Question: What book changed your life?

Comment on this post

Why does it matter who hosts "The Tonight Show"?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 22, 2010 by Eric Ringham (28 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

It's Conan O'Brien's last day as host of "The Tonight Show." In a week of serious news out of Washington and Haiti, the late night TV wars have attracted what even he says is disproportionate attention. Today's Question: Why does it matter who hosts "The Tonight Show"?

Comments texted to MPR:

I am not sure why all the attention is being paid to the late night TV wars. I guess that it is news but on a scale with all the other things that are happening in the world, it really doesn't garner that amount or magnitude of attention that it has been receiving. -Richard, St. Paul, MN

Issues of fairness and justice need to apply even in late night world. NBC is another corporation acting without integrity and calling it 'just business'. -Helen, Minneapolis, MN

I love late night humor at bedtime so its a daily ritual and therefore important to people. At 38 years old, only Conan is funny. -Cory, Minneapolis, MN

It doesn't matter who hosts the Tonight Show. Celebrities and entertainment are mere tools used by the capitalist system to distract people from what matters... -anonymous

It matters because U.S. Audiences don't know the difference between news and entertainment. -Paul

Because people will always cling to entertainment regardless of, or in response to, current events. -anonymous

Because some hosts are funny and some are not. -anonymous

Comment on this post

What's your best cold-weather survival tip?

Posted at 5:00 AM on January 5, 2010 by Eric Ringham (32 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Anyone who's lived here a few years has plenty of strategies for getting through the winter. But days like these call for fresh ideas. What's your best cold-weather survival tip?

Comments texted to MPR:

A hot bath followed by a blanket and a book. Never fails. -Ellie Hutchison, Shoreview, MN

My best cold weather tip is to always have a spare blanket or sleeping bag in your trunk just in case. A good shovel too if you have room. -Alan, Ham Lake, MN

If you wear enough clothes, like 3-4 pairs of shirts and pants, you can't even feel the cold. Wear gloves, etc. too! -Shaun, Moorhead, MN

Dress warmly and enjoy the cold, hang out in the fish house! -Kathleen Kallis, Lake Bronson, MN

Wear headphones and a hat! -Katie Banken, Saint Paul, MN

Winter survival tip: Get outta Dodge! Mexico is nice. -Jeremy

A vacation planned to a warmer climate to look forward to in February. -anonymous

Eliminating cotton and replacing it with wool and high tech synthetics. Add a down coat and you're bulletproof! Mom always said: "there's no bad weather, just bad clothing." -Ann, Cottage Grove, MN

Mukluks are my cold weather survival must. -Lynley, Minneapolis, MN

Two words: long underwear. -Cindy, Arden Hills, MN

Tucson, AZ or any winter escape that allows me to see grass for even a week is my mental relief! -Leigh, Plymouth, MN

Bundling. I still walk the half hour to work and its beautiful. -Sunny, Lauderdale, MN

My strategy is to forget fashion. Go for Carhartts and polar wear! -Christine, Isanti, MN

Comment on this post

Who would you pick as your 2009 Person of the Year?

Posted at 6:00 AM on December 17, 2009 by Eric Ringham (21 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Time magazine announced Wednesday that it had named Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke as its Person of the Year for 2009. Last year, Time's choice was President-elect Barack Obama. Who would you pick as your 2009 Person of the Year?

Comments texted to MPR:

I would nominate Sen. Franken for passing anti-rape legislation recently. -Abdi Takhal, Woodbury, MN

I would choose Joe Lieberman because he has single-handedly killed all hopes of real health reform. What a man. -Mike, Savage, MN

Comment on this post

What was your most memorable moment in this week's snowstorm?

Posted at 6:00 AM on December 10, 2009 by Eric Ringham (12 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Environment/Energy

The storm that swept through Minnesota and the Upper Midwest transformed the landscape, snarled traffic and changed human plans in untold ways. What was your most memorable moment in this week's snowstorm?

Comment on this post

Do you observe any nontraditional holiday traditions?

Posted at 6:00 AM on December 8, 2009 by Eric Ringham (25 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

It's one thing to bake cookies and bring a tree into the house. But some families follow customs that are off the beaten path. Do you observe any nontraditional holiday traditions?

Comment on this post

Does the approach of winter fill you with joy or dread?

Posted at 6:00 AM on December 4, 2009 by Eric Ringham (45 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Daily forecasts have begun to call for flurries. Does the approach of winter fill you with joy or dread?

Comments texted to MPR:

Driving and rush hour plus snow equal mess in the Twin Cities. -Josh, Brooklyn Park, MN

I'm indifferent to the coming of snow, it's a part of living in Minnesota and the seasonal change. But, if it's going to be cold outside, it might as well be white. -Kari, Newport, MN

Both. And winter is never as bad as I dread, and always brings more joy than I expected. The only thing truly dreadful is a too late Spring. -Robert, New Brighton, MN

While there is no joy in snow-snarled driving, there is much joy in gliding through the woods on skis. -Steve Roberts, St Paul, MN

JOY JOY JOY! Hockey, Cross country skiing, ice fishing, sledding, beautiful white blankets of snow! What's not to like?! -Robert, Minneapolis, MN

Absolute joy, bring on the hot chocolate! -Mike, Morris, MN

The joy of the first snowfall will gradually turn to dread over 90 days kinda like a horror movie where the fun turns to dread over 90 min. -anonymous

Comments from "MPR Public Insight" Facebook page:

With much dread, since I hate winter driving, especially at night,with all the crazy speeders out there looking to kill themselves and take others with them. -Michael Kenneth Ireland

Dread. I missed the last two Christmases with family because of snow and bad roads. I'm not hoping for a White Christmas from that mean old song. -Kristin Troska

Share your reply in the comments.

Comment on this post

Does the price of a ticket keep you from attending classical music concerts?

Posted at 6:00 AM on December 3, 2009 by Eric Ringham (36 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

The St. Paul Chamber Orchestra announced Wednesday that it is lowering ticket prices to "promote greater access to concerts." Does the price of a ticket keep you from attending classical music concerts?

Comments texted to MPR:

Attended the U of M opera last week, $20 tickets, even for children. Too much! -Doug, Duluth, MN

No, ticket selling companies' "convenience fees" do! -Nathan, Minneapolis, MN

Comment from Facebook:

Yes, as does the fact I live in the western suburbs and do not like driving into Minneapolis at night, especially in Winter. Have you thought of holding concerts at different sites -- perhaps in churches or schools -- around the Twin Cities, so that Suburbanites don't have to travel to get there? -Michael Kenneth Ireland

Share your reply in the comments.

Comment on this post

Would losing the Vikings hurt Minnesota's quality of life?

Posted at 6:00 AM on November 30, 2009 by Eric Ringham (95 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

Vikings owner Zygi Wilf has balked at efforts to extend the team's lease at the Metrodome. While he says he has no plans to leave Minnesota, Wilf insists that the state's political leaders must find a way to help the team acquire a new stadium. Would losing the Vikings hurt Minnesota's quality of life?

Comment on this post

What story in your community needs more attention?

Posted at 6:00 AM on November 16, 2009 by Eric Ringham (17 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

An interactive discussion today at MPR looks at new models for regional journalism.
What story in your community needs more attention?

Comment on this post

What does the opening of deer season mean to your family?

Posted at 6:00 AM on November 6, 2009 by Eric Ringham (22 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Environment/Energy

Saturday is opening day of Minnesota's firearm season on white-tailed deer. According to the Department of Natural Resources, about half a million hunters participate in the hunt each year. What does the opening of deer season mean to your family?

Comment texted to MPR:

What hunting means to my family? Dad is gone for two days to be alone and think about life. I don't care for deer as food. If I shoot one, it'll be donated. Hope I don't though! I have a hard time de-boning a chicken! -Don, St. Paul, MN

Comment on this post

What book does the best job of transporting you to a different place?

Posted at 6:00 AM on October 28, 2009 by Eric Ringham (33 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

On today's "Midmorning," Kerri Miller and former librarian Nancy Pearl discuss books that carry the reader to other places. What book does the best job of transporting you to a different place?

Comment on this post

Do chickens belong in the city?

Posted at 6:00 AM on October 22, 2009 by Eric Ringham (15 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

In an effort to become more self-reliant, some urban dwellers have taken to raising chickens for their eggs. But calls to Animal Control suggest that not all of them understand the responsibilities of the chicken farmer. Do chickens belong in the city?

Comment on this post

What beloved children's books should not be adapted to the screen?

Posted at 6:00 AM on October 19, 2009 by Eric Ringham (20 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The film adaptation of Maurice Sendak's "Where the Wild Things Are" opened this weekend. What beloved children's books should not be adapted to the screen?

Comments texted to MPR:

"A Wrinkle in Time". -Melissa, Duluth, MN

"Goodnight Moon" should not be adapted to big screen. -Lisa, St. Paul, MN

No Dr. Suess should be filmed. Did you see "Cat in the Hat"? -Donna Grandin, ND

"Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs". -Charlie, Minneapolis, MN

"The Giving Tree" by Sendak. -Sue S., White Bear Township, MN

There is no limit to what can be adapted to the screen. To suggest that we should limit it is to stifle creativity. -Matt, Brainerd, MN

As long as someone like Spike Jones directs, the book is in good hands. -Josh

Why don't you just call it "the elderly hate change"? What a silly and loaded question. -Mookie, St. Paul, MN

No children's books should be made into movies. Children should be reading, not watching a screen. -Robert Collins, Eden Prairie, MN

From Twitter:

"Everybody Poops". -@jpwest

Goodnight Moon. -@andreakremer

Share your reply in the comments: What beloved children's books should not be adapted to the screen?

Comment on this post

How willing are you to help pay for a new Vikings stadium?

Posted at 6:00 AM on October 5, 2009 by Anna Weggel (129 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

Last week the Minnesota Vikings renewed their drive for a new stadium to be built largely at public expense. How willing are you to help pay for a new Vikings stadium?

Given the state's budget crisis and budget cuts to such vital needs as education and health care I feel it is appalling to fund a new stadium with taxpayer dollars. I am outraged. -Lisa Kleingarn, Minneapolis, MN

I love the Vikings but unless Ziggy is going to put up around half for his team's new stadium neither will I. -Alan, Bloomington, MN

I'm not willing to pay for any portion of any new stadium. Enough is enough...middle class America subsidizing Millionaire Players and their Billionaire Employers, when will it end? -Jim, Saint Paul, MN

Zero for Zygi. -Mark Buckholz, Minneapolis, MN

I would rather pay for new schools instead of stadiums. Our tax money is not endless; some sensible prioritization please. -Kate Herberg, Mankato, MN

Stadium funding is inappropriate use of tax dollars; especially when education funding and other expenses that benefit everyone are lacking. -Suzanne, Minneapolis, MN

Absolutely not! Let's be the state that proudly ends the era of supporting billionaire beggars! -Laura, Eden Prairie, MN

Yes, if we get a percentage of the revenue once it's built. -Marty, St. Paul, MN

Public money should go into a new stadium ONLY if we get an equity stake in the franchise, with our portion of profits to go back into public coffers. -Peter, St. Paul, MN

Any stadium funding mechanisms should be voluntary. User fees, a racino, etc., can provide a reasonable compromise solution to this question. -Wade, St. Joe, MN

Why would i pay for something I'll never use? I'm already paying for the Target Field, I'm not a baseball or football fan anyway. Let the owner pay for it or let the Vikings go. -Mark

I'd be glad to pay for the public health option - Vikings never. -Linda, Minneapolis, MN

It does not matter what more than 50 percent of Minnesotans think when the commission, like with the Twins, is SOLD OUT. -E.R.Sotomayor

The Vikings play eight games a year...my kid's school runs 215 days annually, and the experience lasts more than four quarters and an overnight hotel stay. No question where I'd invest 950 million. -anonymous text message

Comment on this post

What's your favorite memory of baseball at the Metrodome?

Posted at 6:00 AM on October 2, 2009 by Eric Ringham (25 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The Minnesota Twins are about to finish their final season in the Metrodome before moving to their new home at Target Field. What's your favorite memory of baseball at the Metrodome?

Comment on this post

What would a Chicago Olympics mean for the Midwest?

Posted at 6:00 AM on October 1, 2009 by Eric Ringham (8 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy, International affairs

Members of the International Olympic Committee will vote Friday on the city that will host the 2016 Games. Among the contenders is Chicago, with strong support from Barack and Michelle Obama. What would a Chicago Olympics mean for the Midwest?

My husband is a trucker and he hates driving through Chicago now because of congestion. The Olympics are really going to make a bigger mess of that city. -Mechelle, Lake Park, MN

Share your reply in the comments: What would a Chicago Olympics mean for the Midwest?

Comment on this post

When is texting inappropriate?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 30, 2009 by Eric Ringham (21 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Science/Technology

You've probably never sent a text message from a church pew, or while driving, or during a lecture in class. But you've seen people do that and more. When is texting inappropriate?

Whenever your attention is respectfully required by others (i.e. While at church, when driving, etc.) -anonymous text message

Texting is inappropriate when driving mainly because it is illegal, but at any other time it is just a extension of your freedom of speech. -Pat, Maplewood, MN

Texting in church! The best use of an otherwise wasted hour. -Jim, Saint Paul, MN

Texting is efficient and important best to do when not talking to another or driving. -Jeff, St. Cloud, MN

Texting is just a tool, and is only inappropriate where inattention of any sort is rude or dangerous. Used appropriately, texting is a great resource! -anonymous text message

Texting, with other new social networking tools, are eroding in-person communication skills to efficient technophiles living through avatars. -anonymous text message

Comment on this post

What's your favorite place in Minnesota to enjoy the fall?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 28, 2009 by Anna Weggel (21 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

At this time of year it can be hard to find vacancies along the North Shore or the St. Croix River Valley. But there are plenty of other spots to enjoy the weather and color of the season. What's your favorite place in Minnesota to enjoy the fall?

The best way to enjoy fall is to snuggle under blankets in the sun-room. All the pretty, none of the cold. -@k_schoe

Walking through the Bird Sanctuary near Lake Harriet. -@loriwilson23

I say canoeing the StCroix. -@jonbenson

Duluth is the place to be! Plenty to do, beautiful landscape/ views, and great beer. Couldn't ask for more, Autumn or otherwise! -@_ants_

My favorite place to enjoy the fall colors is my backyard. -Lynne, Prior Lake, MN

St. Croix River valley by boat. -Bill, Minneapolis, MN

Comment on this post

What's your approach to praising children?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 24, 2009 by Eric Ringham (12 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Recent research suggests that parents and teachers who heap praise on children may not be doing them any favors. What's your approach to praising children?

Comment on this post

Should parents be held responsible if guests of their kids drink?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 14, 2009 by Eric Ringham (24 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Health

The St. Paul City Council is considering an ordinance that would hold you responsible if underage drinking occurs in your home or rental property, regardless of whether you supply the liquor. Similar ordinances are in effect in other cities, including Chaska. Should parents be held responsible if guests of their kids drink?

Comment on this post

How will you remember the summer of '09?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 8, 2009 by Eric Ringham (26 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

For some, the summer just past may be defined by its news stories: The Senate recount. The health care debate. The passing of Walter Cronkite and Edward Kennedy. For others, the summer may have marked the birth of a child or the loss of a job. How will you remember the summer of '09?

Comment on this post

What did you learn at the Fair this year?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 7, 2009 by Eric Ringham (8 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Education

In 1902, the St. Paul and Minneapolis School Boards pushed the opening day of school back to the Monday after the State Fair. Education authorities stated that there was "more to be learned in a single day at the fair than in double the time at school or college." What did you learn at the Fair this year?

Comment on this post

Could a gory video make you a better driver?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 3, 2009 by Eric Ringham (22 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Science/Technology, Transportation

A British public-service video offers a graphic depiction of a car accident involving teen-agers who text while driving. The video has spread quickly around the Web, but it's unclear whether the gruesome images will actually change anyone's behavior. Could a gory video make you a better driver?

Comment on this post

What's left on your summer to-do list?

Posted at 6:00 AM on September 2, 2009 by Anna Weggel (10 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

The State Fair closes on Monday and students will soon be heading back to school. What haven't you accomplished this summer that you set out to do? What's left on your summer to-do list?

Comment on this post

When you spend a day at the State Fair, what's your strategy?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 27, 2009 by Eric Ringham (13 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Among the animal barns and the food booths, from Machinery Hill to the Midway, the Minnesota State Fair is crowded with new attractions and old traditions. It can be a challenge to hit all the nostalgic spots and still get the most out of the latest exhibits. When you spend a day at the State Fair, what's your strategy?

Mini doughnuts for breakfast, prontos for lunch, cheese curds for a snack and finish off with cookies. There's no such thing as a diet at the Fair! -Michael, St. Paul, MN

Start when it opens at the cow barns so my city children could see the loving care farm kids give their animals as they prepare for judging, see where milk comes from, and experience the lovely aroma of the fair. End with the art show where it is quiet and air conditioned AND there are clean bathrooms. -anonymous text message

Eat just eat. -anonymous text message

Share your reply in the comments: What's your State Fair strategy?

Comment on this post

How has your experience with divorce affected your attitudes toward marriage?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 26, 2009 by Eric Ringham (46 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Race/Gender

Second and third marriages are more likely than first marriages to end in divorce. And according to the Gallup Poll, more Americans than ever consider divorce morally acceptable. How has your experience with divorce affected your attitudes toward marriage?

Comment on this post

What does Woodstock mean to you?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 14, 2009 by Anna Weggel (27 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

40 years ago, 32 acts performed over three days and four nights at Max Yasgur's 600-acre dairy farm in Bethel, New York. A half million concert goers looked on as Joan Baez, Grateful Dead, Janis Joplin, The Who, Jimi Hendrix and many others defined a generation. If you were there, wish you had been, or were otherwise marked by those three days in August of 1969, what does Woodstock mean to you?

At Woodstock we learned we were all in the same prison. We succeeded in rattling the cage, but we did not break free. -anonymous text message

Woodstock? It was just a big, drug and mud soaked outdoor rock concert in NY. 40 years ago I was an 11 year old girl from CT who had just moved to a new town in NH and didnt know a soul. I knew about the concert -it was in the news- but I was more concerned about fitting into my new junior high. Did it define my generation? Not at all. It was something for the bored teenagers of the privileged who didn't have a job that summer. -Lynne, Prior Lake, MN

Share your reply in the comments: What does Woodstock mean to you?

Comment on this post

What is the ideal spectator event for Minnesota to host and why?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 13, 2009 by Anna Weggel (21 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

This week, Hazeltine National Golf Club in Chaska is hosting the 91st PGA Championship -- a major coup, even for the state with more golfers per capita than any other. In the past, Minnesota also has welcomed the NCAA Final Four, NHL All-Star Game, WE Fest Country Musical Festival and the Republican National Convention. What else is out there? What is the ideal spectator event for Minnesota to host - and why?

SCCA pro rally is the ideal spec. Sport (ojibwe forest). It gets the spectators involved, rather than sitting and watching. -Dustin, Montgomery, MN

The Olympic summer games of course! -Brian, St. Paul, MN

Nothing...stop overrunning us with crowds. -Terri

MN should host the world cup ... please don't say soccer...it's football. -Ebba

Comment on this post

Is owning a home part of your American Dream?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 12, 2009 by Anna Weggel (28 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

A recent study shows the rate of homeownership in America has declined by more than 2 percent since 2004, and is projected to drop even more over the coming years. Has homeownership lost its luster in the wake of the mortgage crisis and recession? Is owning a home part of your American Dream?

Yes, owning a home is part of my "American Dream." But I'm realistic & could never afford all the extra bills & responsibilities. -@ELBfoto

Although my wife and I are going through a foreclosure right now, I got to be a homeowner as a 25 year old! In what other country would that even be possible? We plan on doing it again someday when we have more money. -Kyle Sumrow, Plymouth, MN

An immigrant owning a home in America is a part of mine and my parents American dream. -Igor Flider, Maple Grove, MN

As odd as it may seem, owning a home is not a part of my American Dream. Am I in the minority there? -@AHKaufman

If the American Dream is to watch Star Wars at whatever volume I see fit, then count me in! -Jeremy, Fargo, ND

My American dream is to have the freedom and flexibility to work and live in different places. I was able to take advantage of a job opportunity in the Brainerd area and then another opportunity to rent a lake home that I could never afford to own. Home ownership can be a beast of burden keeping people from pursuing other dreams and is not for everyone. -anonymous text message

Yes, home ownership falls into my idea of the American dream. Preferably in the city, not the suburbs. -@leesejared

It's not my American Dream, but I hope to buy one this year for the free $8000 anyway. -anonymous text message

If the American Dream is owning a home the Minnesota dream is owning a cabin on a lake! We bought a a cabin in the fall 2009 because of the very low prices. -anonymous text message

No! Perhaps property. But that's as far as I'd go. -@jenniferphd

The American dream is about freedom, not home ownership. Owning a home is not appropriate for everyone. -anonymous text message

Share your reply in the comments: Is owning a home part of your American Dream?

Comment on this post

What ties you to where you live?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 10, 2009 by Eric Ringham (32 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Money Magazine recently rated Chanhassen, Chaska, Lino Lakes and Owatonna as among the best 100 small towns (population 8,500 to 50,000) to live in the country. Rankings were based on strong local economies, good schools, affordable homes and low crime. But how do you measure the soul of a community? What ties you to the place where you live?

My wife and I live with my inlaws because of a foreclosure and we have nowhere else to go! -Kyle, Plymouth, MN

Why St Paul? Coherent work, circle of friends, 2 cities at my beck & call, a creaky yellow farmhouse: a movable feast. -Bruce Parker

I moved here from Uptown to go to UWRF, never thought I'd fall so in love w/ a small town. I love the sense of community, always running into people i know, and i appreciate the support the town gives to the music and arts community. I will certainly miss RF when i graduate! -Kyrsten, River Falls, WI

Nothing. I'm moving out of Detroit Lakes, MN next year to get to a bigger city! Although It's beautiful here. -Sara Refsland, Detroit Lakes, MN

Great schools in St. Paul. Quality of life. Good place to raise kids. -Therese

No money ties me to where i live. -Anthony Sundgaard

What ties me to Minnesota is the beautiful trees and people. -Sara, Melrose, MN

My children's schools. -Lynne, Prior Lake, MN

Upside down on my mortgage.... -Billy, Hugo, MN

Location, location, location. -Paul Picard, Lauderdale, MN

Great Neighborhoods. -Bill, St. Paul, MN

Ties to place I live? A: debt! Don't misunderstand, I LOVE MN, its people and environmental diversity...don't want to leave, but debt stops me considering alternatives. -Travis, Minneapolis, MN

What ties me? My mortgage? I kid. 3 generations of my wife's family ties me to small town Montgomery. -anonymous text message

Food is what ties me to home. :) -anonymous text message

Share your reply in the comments: What ties you to where you live?

Comment on this post

Would you donate your body for use after death?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 7, 2009 by Eric Ringham (32 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Religion/Ethics

Starting this weekend, paying customers will once again be looking at preserved, posed corpses in a Twin Cities exhibit. Meanwhile, an Illinois woman has received the heart of a Minnesota soldier who died from wounds suffered in battle in Afghanistan. Whether for science, commercial use or to save the life of another person, agreeing to give up your earthly remains is likely to involve some soul-searching. Would you donate your body for use after death?

I don't think i would let my body be donated. I wouldn't really care what happens to my body, let my family decide. -Nathan, IN

Of course i would donate my body. It would be selfish and inhumane not to. -Alix Sophia, Minneapolis, MN

I've already arranged to have myself sent to the body farm in TN when my time comes. -Cat, Minneapolis, MN

Yes - I am pro-recycling so yes. -Casey Nordendale, St. Paul, MN

Comment on this post

Does alcohol have a proper role at campus sports events?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 6, 2009 by Eric Ringham (23 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Students who have been found intoxicated and ejected from a Gopher football game will have to take a Breathalyzer test before they can attend another game, under a policy being developed for the University of Minnesota's new football stadium. The plan would tolerate no alcohol in the system of a student too young to drink and only some in students of legal drinking age. Officials are trying to limit rowdy behavior, which they say is closely related to alcohol use. Does alcohol have a proper role at campus sports events?

Most of us enjoy high school games w/o beer. The game, your friends, a cool evening are what make it fun. -Leigh Webber, Blaine, MN

I don't think those who are responsible drinkers should be penalized because some people are idiots. I would have thought all the U brainpower would be creative. -Lisa Threadgill, St. Louis Park, MN

Alcohol at college sporting events is inevitable. College kids find a way to drink by either binging before the game or sneaking in alcohol. . Allowing alcohol to be sold at the event may prevent binge drinking before the event by students who know they will not be able to drink once there. -anonymous text message

Comment on this post

Do you want to know your neighbors?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 4, 2009 by Eric Ringham (20 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Security

Tonight, people in thousands of neighborhoods around the country will gather to get to know each other on National Night Out and Night to Unite. The idea is to make communities safer by spreading information about fighting crime and preventing drug abuse. Do you want to know your neighbors?

My neighbors are great! We all enjoy spending time together in the alley. -anonymous text message

Absolutely! But i wasn't invited. -anonymous text message

Not all of them...maybe a few. -anonymous text message

Comment on this post

Would you trade your books for an electronic version?

Posted at 6:00 AM on August 3, 2009 by Eric Ringham (51 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Amazon recently released a new version of its Kindle book reader, a device that allows users to buy and read books, newspapers and other publications in electronic form. Would you trade your books for an electronic version?

No. Amazon's system allows them to remove books from your Kindle, and limit the number of downloads. You don't own ebooks, you just rent them. -Ryan, St. Paul, MN

I heart books! But for travel purposes I'd really like a kindle to cut down on bulk/damage. -Melissa, Mankato, MN

Never! Ill keep my books along with the letters i recieve in the mail, my typewriters and my records. Computers crash, are too expensive and break down way too easy and way too often. When they work like the phone I'm texting from they are convenient. -Noah, Hastings, MN

For something i just want to read i wouldn't mind a kindle but books that i'm passionate about losing the feel of the paper and the binding would be like the loss of the big pieces of art we lost when vinyl records went away. -Brandon Carriere, Le Sueur, MN

Novels-YES!, business and personal-NO! I think that both have a purpose, but we talk as if a person has to use one or the other. -Harvey Rupert

I think both ebooks and traditional books will coexist. I see a day when we will consume most of our media on electronic devices, and traditional books will be ordered as a boutique item on a one by one basis where you will have choices in paper, binding, and personalized messages. -Simon, St. Paul, MN

No way i am too vain i like displaying to all who visit my home all the books I've read. -Mike, Savage, MN

I have a Kindle. While I love it for reading all the novels I read (and would give away if I had purchased them), and for all the free sample chapters that help me shop , it will never fully replace books for me. I want to own some in hard copy, write in many, and hold others. Call me sentimental, but the visceral experience of holding or using a book I own is fundamental to my daily life. -Lynne Silva-Breen

What about passing on your favorite books to your kids or nieces and nephews? How many times have you "lost" electronic documents when your device "crashes?" I would like to have books on a shelf for my 10 year old to turn on to. -Terry, St. Cloud, MN

You can't take a paper book away from me like recently happened on the Kindle with some Orwell titles. I'll keep the paper, thanks. -Brian

Regarding ebooks: Anything that saves a tree is worth it. -Alex, Red Wing, MN

Does anyone else see the irony of ''big brother'' removing the Orwell books from kindle? -Brian, Grand Forks, MN

Not for me. I have more than 2000 research volumes. There is no way that most of these books will ever end up as an ebook. To say nothing of quality pictures. -anonymous text message

Absolutely not! I'm a 28 year old guy living in new york city and my most prized possession is my book shelf. -anonymous text message

No way! Aren't we trying to find ways to depend LESS on electricity and energy? Books are easy to share, wonderful to hold, and do not require a plug-in! -anonymous text message

Half the fun of buying old books is reading what people wrote in them. If books are all put online, an entire genre of thoughtful gifts will disappear! -anonymous text message

Share your reply in the comments: Would you trade your books for an electronic version?

Comment on this post

Why do we give so much attention to sports figures?

Posted at 6:00 AM on July 29, 2009 by Eric Ringham (14 Comments)
Filed under: Culture

Months of rumors and speculation came to an end Tuesday with the news that Brett Favre will remain in retirement. The news disappointed Minnesota fans who had become increasingly excited about the possibility that the legendary Green Bay quarterback would join the Vikings. Why do we give so much attention to sports figures?

Comment on this post

How important to you is the U.S. mail in the Internet age?

Posted at 6:00 AM on July 28, 2009 by Eric Ringham (47 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

The U.S. Postal Service is considering the closure of thousands of post offices around the country, including two dozen in Minnesota. Officials blame sharply declining mail volume, due in part to the rise in Web-based alternatives to traditional mail. How important to you is the U.S. mail in the Internet age?

Having grown up in the internet age, I find the USPS to be mostly useless. These closings are to be expected and welcomed. -Nick, Inver Grove Heights, MN

I am 23, and the only time writing letters was important to me was basic training. Nowadays when friends go away, they say Facebook me, not write me. -Durrell, Minneapolis, MN

Close them. We don't need a office in every town. -Mike Rowan, Big Lake, MN

Even though I'm a Net junkie, there's still nothing like getting a real letter in the mail. The Post Office needs to stay. -John Charles Wilson, Minneapolis, MN

Holding a letter in my hands and knowing that person took the time and effort to write it and send it to me is an experience not possible through email. -Noah, Hastings, MN

Close them and go to THREE day a week delivery. -anonymous text message

Share your reply in the comments: How important to you is the U.S. mail in the Internet age?

Comment on this post

When, if ever, is public art a good use of taxpayers' money?

Posted at 6:00 AM on July 15, 2009 by Eric Ringham (15 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy, Politics/Government

In a hearing today, members of the St. Paul City Council are considering whether to dedicate funds to the creation and maintenance of public art. When, if ever, is public art a good use of taxpayers' money?

I believe the tax money toward public art benefits the local tourism economy and public appearances. My vote: better than building professional stadiums. -Steven Larson, Duluth, MN

Art is a good use of taxpayers' money when it creates a cultural environment that brings businesses and jobs to the area, especially young families and entrepreneurs. -Lauren, Minneapolis, MN

Art and culture is always an easy target in times of economic hardship but many would argue that it is these times when we need art and culture the most as a way to give ourselves perspective and to create dialog and a sense of community. To many public art can seem to be a luxury but for most it is a necessity as it is a component of the environment we live in. In the same way that one pays attention to aesthetic detail in their homes shouldn't we also give our communities that same treatment? There also tends to be a notion that public art is competing for dollars that would otherwise go to social services and this is rarely the case. -Melinda Childs, Minneapolis, MN

Simple: ALWAYS! Art improves everyones quality of life! -anonymous text message

Comment on this post

Should employers be able to regulate your personal life?

Posted at 6:00 AM on July 14, 2009 by Eric Ringham (14 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Religion/Ethics

The Pentagon is considering a recommendation that it ban tobacco use among all members of the military. Likewise, professional sports teams routinely prohibit athletes from skiing, riding motorcycles or playing pick-up basketball due to risk of injury. Should employers be able to regulate your personal life?

No. Unless it is detrimental to the job or poorly reflects values of the profession personal life is just that...personal. That's like asking if health care providers should bar obese people from working in the health care profession since it doesn't portray a healthy lifestyle. There needs to be a limit to personal interference. I may have my disdain for obesity, substance use,ignorance and rudeness but to each his own...I am no more superior than the next person. -Teri Gibbons, Rochester, MN

The fine line between work and personal life has been wearing away for some time. As work life and personal life start to blur employers are naturally going to try to regulate the behavior of their employees since they now represent their respective companies both in and out of the work place. I don't think it's right for employers to regulate the average blue collar worker. Regulating people outside of the workplace feels like an assault on individual rights. I can understand some regulation of military or professional sports because their physical condition directly relates to their job performance... but that's a slippery slope. -Jonathan Campbell, Hopkins, MN

I use to think America was founded and based on freedom? I guess pretty soon employers, along with government, will be able to regulate how many and when their employees can decide to have children. -Kimberly Johannsen, Shoreview, MN

I am a strong believer in positive reinforcement to a healthier lifestyle . So incentives towards that goal make sense to me. If that can be accomplished by companies through their health plans , it will reduce the overall cost of treatment after the onset of issues. We must work towards preemptive model with respect to health care . Companies in the US can push that forward . Outside of health I do not see anything wrong with a personal contract which precludes destructive behavior. -Tom Mallon, Minneapolis, MN

Not sure those examples are comparable. Pro athletes have professionally negotiated contracts that pay them handsomely. Army grunts have almost infinitely less leverage with their employer. This isn't a yes/no question. Would it be sane for employers to mandate a perfectly healthy lifestyle, including exercise (low impact - watch the joints!), no fat, no meat, no white wine, no breathing polluted air? Obviously not, but it does make sense to provide incentives for behavior that will enhance productivity - subsidized gym memberships, etc. We're working more than ever, we need to keep our private lives for ourselves. -Ben Gillies, St. Paul, MN

When in a college track program, I was not allowed to swim or ski. No hardship then. Employers are not allowed to ask personal questions at interview time, therefore they should not be able to dictate behavior after hiring. I gave my hours to each employer as negotiated for pay and benefits. They should never be able to then Change the Rules after agreeing to the hours and responsibilities. -John Reay, Minneapolis, MN

I find a military smoking ban absurd. I'd like to see how they plan to tell infantrymen in a prolonged fire fight that the no smoking light is on. -Jess

Two chief issues come to mind: (1) Timing. There's a difference between ad hoc changing regulations after the employee is hired vs. those written up-front into an initial hiring contract. The latter seems more reasonable, the former is borderline fascistic. (2) Purpose & Symmetry. Presumably, regulations serve the betterment of the company. In this era of run-it-to-the-ground and slash&burn management, off-shoring, and bailing out, the next consideration is the basic asymmetry of the problem: employers desire to dictate how employees must live, but apparently management is free to practice company-self-destructive behavior? -Paul Bramscher, Circle Pines, MN

I believe there are professions out there that have reasonable expectations on performance that overlap into personal life. I also believe there are professions that have little, if any, overlap and should not have "off-duty" life activities scrutinized by their employer. I believe this is something that requires healthy debate and an open mind on the part of both employers and employees. -Leanne Kunze, Waconia, MN

My answer is simple. As long as the employer bears a financial burden (whether it be in higher health insurance rates or workers compensation costs) for personal habits that affect your health, they should be able to issue some rules in regards to those personal habits while you work. People can't have it both ways, to have their lung cancer treatment paid for by the employer sponsored health insurance AND refuse to give up smoking while at work. -Kari Harding, Canby, MN

In the case of the military, the contract you enter essentially states that you are property of the military during the duration of your enlistment. As far as employment at will I don't believe that an employer should have the right to dictate your lifestyle. That could be a very slippery slope that would be very hard to back peddle from. That kind of control encroaches on the individual civil rights and liberties that are the corner stone of american citizenship. -Jesse Zeimet, Minneapolis, MN

No!! This sets a dangerous precedent and borders on violating one's right to privacy. -Sandra Henry, Bolingbrook, IL

Yes, if a reasonable person would think that the banned behavior could harm the company. Companies have a right to do what is in their best interest. If you own a football team and a player gets hurt and can't play, you loose money. So, you can say, "If you want to play for my team, you can't ski or ride a motorcycle." Jobs are voluntary. The government, on the other hand, should not be able to regulate my personal life. -Chris Erickson, Minneapolis, MN

No, but they do, always have, and always will. Even if laws may keep them from firing those employees they do not consider to be the kind of people they wish to employ, they can and will retaliate however they can, and reward those that do as they suggest. -Paul Lareau, Little Canada, MN

You can not include situations where there is an employment contract in this debate. Professional sports and military both have contracts and therefore the employer can regulate what ever they want within the bounds of the contract. For the military, smoking should have been banned long ago, who wants a soldier to be in battle and have a twitchy finger because they need a fix? Where the employment is at-will, employers should not be able to regulate your personal life, this includes blogs and other items as long as they are not disparaging to the employer. -Richard Garnett, Minneapolis, MN

Only if said banned behavior affects the job. -Dustin, Montgomery, MN

If you don't like what an employer is asking in exchange for employment...don't work for them! I have a choice which company I work for, I do NOT have a choice which government governs me. -Dennis Fisher, Dayton, MN

I think if it could potentially affect your job performance by a considerable amount, it is reasonable for your employer to ask. For example, if you were a model, your employer may not want you getting inappropriate tattoos or making drastic appearance changes as it could affect sales of product, the image a company is trying to sell, and so on. Let's keep in mind that people apply for a job of their own free will. If you do not like the demands or requirements of a job, then you can always look somewhere else. Although I do think there is a fine line between what is okay and not okay for an employer to ask of their employees. -Keli Holtmeyer, Maple Grove, MN

No! But they do. No explanations or discussions needed and they will continue to regulate personal lives until folks realize they have lost a lost of basic freedoms along with comfort zones. This regulation is subtle and not painful yet but it's coming. Period. -Bertie Williams

I am amazed at people's thinking; on the one hand people absolutely resent a government health plan, because it might be socialistic. On the other hand they allow the government to regulate their private actions...No smoking, no abortions, no gays in the military... I dont get it.. are these regulations not interfering with the social texture of this society??? -Regina Rippel, St. Paul, MN

Share your reply in the comments: Should employers be able to regulate your personal life?

Comment on this post

Is illegally sharing music immoral?

Posted at 6:00 AM on July 8, 2009 by Eric Ringham (38 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Religion/Ethics

Jammie Thomas-Rasset of Brainerd has asked a judge to reduce the $1.9 million penalty she has been ordered to pay for illegally sharing music. What do you think: Is illegally sharing music immoral?

Yes, it is immoral because it is cheating the artist and the mechanisms that the artist depends upon to sell work. Would the people who illegally share the music be willing to work for no pay? Not likely. If artists cannot make a living from making their music - does it not seem to be the case that there will be fewer full time musicians? -Claire Thoen, St. Paul, MN

Illegally sharing music is not immoral, per se. But to the extent to which Jammie Thomas-Rasset did so, and continued to do so after a warning and previous suit, was a severe violation of intellectual property rights and an arrogant intrusion on musicians' ownership. She and others like her should, of course, not go to jail, and I even agree that she should pay only a portion of the penalty. But I also feel that "music hackers" who download and share on a large scale should suffer the consequences, and not get away with thumbing their noses at artists and the industry like Jammie did. -John Ervin, Minneapolis, MN

Illegally sharing music is immoral. That means I'm frequently immoral. But suing peoples faces off for doing things that feel free is equally immoral. I believe that we need to create subscription based streaming models that feel free but permit artists to monetize their work. We also need to look towards organizations like SoundExchange, BMI, ASCAP and SESAC to stay on top of how people are listening to music and collecting performance fees from the people that host that music. A performance royalty fee could be added to the purchase of those items most likely to be used in pirating (Itunes, Ipod, CDRs, Vinyl to MP3 converters). This fee is not to say that every single piece of media is used for such things, but more to say that this a new format that consumers are consuming music on. At one point (not sure if it's current) ASCAP received a small bit of money from CDR sales. Pretty smart. -Sean McPherson, St. Paul, MN

Immoral? No, not unless one defines morality as following the letter of the law. And pretty good argument can be made that certain laws themselves are immoral. If one defines morality as care and responsible treatment of one's fellow human beings, then it's a stretch to call music sharing as immoral. Illegal? Yes, at present. One might argue that a $1.9m judgment against an individual, particularly one without astonishing means, is immoral. It would relegate Ms. Thomas-Rasset to destitution for the rest of her life, unless she breaks more laws and goes on the lamb. One has to wonder how on earth that judgment fits the crime. -Mary Cody, Baxter, MN

Yes. Unless you have a compelling argument against a lawful regulation, it is wrong and immoral to violate it. Even then you should be prepared to be punished for your disobedience. As for commercial music, trying to exploit someone else's talent, I believe it is wrong, immoral, and foolish. Make that "stupid." -Gord Prickett, Aitkin, MN

As a music copyright attorney, it is clear that illegally sharing music has its consequences. But in a highly-evolving environment...laws, legislation, and morality will rarely keep pace with technology. Was the "free and shared" music broadcast via radio "immoral"? Was the technology of radio...immoral? Embracing technology -- and its significant impact on intellectual property -- is our current challenge. New Media necessarily means New Rules. As difficult as "free" and "illegal file sharing" may sound to us, the new simple truth is: "Before an audience will Pay Royalties...they must Pay Attention". We cannot play whack-a-mole with technology, be it radio...Napster...or the next next thing. We must be innovators...open to the nuanced negotiations of "licensing" intellectual property...as opposed to trying to snuff out brilliant technologies that should rightly be harnessed to broaden the knowledge base of arts and sciences. -Ron Sobel, St. Paul, MN

While I respect that artists and labels deserve to be paid for their work, the RIAA isn't going to save itself by sticking to archaic business practices nor suing individuals who download music. Considering the popularity of iTunes and today's prevalent marketing strategy of giving away your hit single via mp3, a court ruling like this doesn't send a warning message not to download music. It sends a message that the music industry still doesn't understand we're in a new environment that requires innovation and creativity to monetize. -Greg Swan, Chaska, MN

It's wrong so yes, It's not moral! -Maria

Well, the question itself it little tricky but answer must be YES as 'Illegal' = 'immoral'. Question is how do yo define 'illegal' sharing. -Syed Uddin, Bloomington, MN

Yes. Illegally sharing music is theft. There's no moral ground claimed by being "against the big bad record companies" however antiquated and regressive their methods. The purchase of downloaded music involves compensation for the artist's work. So who is Ms Thomas-Rasset or anyone else to decide that that artist is not worthy of market-set compensation? You wouldn't steal a bag of apples from the grocery store then hand them out on the street. It's the same for music and any other intellectual property. -Simon Wiltshire, Minnetonka, MN

This depends on how you define "immoral." It is and should be illegal because there are strict copyright laws in the USA. As a musician and composer myself I would be a little unhappy if someone were to tape / record or otherwise "take" my music and use it for something other than what it was intended for. In other words, from my perspective it IS immoral. -Lisa Ragsdale, Minneapolis, MN

If the industry could have tracked LP to cassette taping and sharing, a lot of us would have gotten in a lot of trouble. -Jenn B

Plain and simply, no. The only group of people this negatively effects are the big time record execs. Musicians profit mostly from merchandise, ticket sells, commercial use of their music/image, etc. The more people hear their music, the more popular and profitable the band/artist will become. Before there were CDs and MP3s we had cassette tapes. Was it illegal then to make a mix tape for a friend? Or yourself? If it was, it wasn't frowned upon. As a musician myself, I would be thrilled to hear my music was well received by others and others and so on. Hence why MySpace has become such a huge hit for musicians to promote themselves. FREE. -Michael Soricelli, Duluth, MN

Such activity as that has 3 strikes against it- it is illegal, immoral, AND unethical! -Tom, Anoka, MN

Well, it is stealing so by definition in my world, it's immoral, though I'm not sure that's the right word. Since there are sites where one can buy the music they want one song at a time, so it's not like there is no option but to steal. All of this said, I think the penalty imposed on the woman in Brainerd IS immoral. It's also ridiculous since she will never be able to pay the fine. Also, I believe that there's a question about whether she actually shared files or not. If not, it's a truly insane fine. -John Hetterick, Plymouth, MN

Illegal music sharing is certainly immoral. It is and should be illegal. Still, the financial penalty in this case is extreme at least. -James B., St. Paul, MN

no, i would say it is not immoral, for the recording industry has been overcharging people for too long, and forcing artists into unfair contracts. music already flows like water, in the internet, and nothing is going to change that. people who share music are helping to liberate the artists and force a change in the music industry to a greater emphasis on the artist, who is the person that matters, not the manager or the executive or the marketing department. sharing music IS marketing; it exposes the artist to more people than they would reach themselves. -Kori Touya, Northfield, MN

File sharing is no more immoral than making a mix tape for that special someone was back in the pre-Internet days. -Ryan, St Paul, MN

Yes. Today's technology makes it possible, with almost no effort, to share music on the net. The fact that it is so easy dims the perception of this as theft. Whether the record companies are rich and powerful or not is not the question here. The music was created by the composer and performer and financed by the record company. Legally and morally, they own the creation and have control over it's use and distribution. If one wishes to create music and give it away on the net as some bands have done, that is their choice. Copyright law exists to protect the people who create art. It is their only protection in most cases. -Steven Anderson, Merrifield, MN

Whether we agree with a law or not, breaking it to financially benefit cannot be categorized as moral. Breaking a law with the intention of proving the law immoral - civil disobedience - means getting caught and calling attention to how the law is unjust. Stealing songs - and let's face it, it's not sharing, it's allowing other people to steal - is not changing a system. It is profiting from it. I'm frustrated by the current copyright system. I think it is corrupt and does not serve the stated purpose to benefit new creative work. However, the answer is for everyone to demand a change in law, not just steal for convenience. -Steve Boland, St. Paul, MN

Downloading music illegally is the same as shoplifting did you run a billion dollar ponzi scheme no, but that doesn't mean you didn't steal it. -Jason, St. Paul, MN

Purchase of creative work protected by copyright, trademark, or patent gives the purchaser the legal write to read, view, or listen to that work at will in accord with the conditions of the sale. "Fair use" allows the purchaser to make an audio recording in one format and later copy it using another format for preservation or convenience. Selling that work, in any format, to another without compensating those who created the original work is stealing. Giving that work to others without cost, or making it available for others to take at will, is also stealing if doing so is prohibited by the terms of the work's sale. Stealing is immoral. -David Leitzman, Saint Joseph, MN

Immoral? Thats a pretty heavy word to use for sharing something as intangible and wonderful as music. -Dave, Minneapolis, MN

I do not think that illegally sharing music is immoral, but it is unethical. As the mother of a young woman who is trying to make a living as a musician, it concerns me that she isn't paid for her music. However, she tells me that she is anxious to have it heard by as many people as possible, so is not bothered when people share it. In the case in question, the penalty is so far from fitting the "crime" that it's as wrong as what Jammie Thomas-Rasset did in the first place, if not more so. It is appropriate for her to have to pay something, perhaps double or triple what she shared, but that's it. -Ginny Levi, Minneapolis, MN

Music file sharing is no different than checking out a CD at my local library. why aren't music executives up in arms about music checked out at libraries? -anonymous text message

What is legal is not necessarily moral. What is illegal is not necessarily immoral. There are three categories of law: civil, criminal, and torts. The law is not even logical. People do not necessarily agree about the morality or immorality of a given action, inaction, or thought. Church organizations do not agree about theological principles. Having said that, I will talk about two unrelated issues: the legal issue, and the moral issue. The musician created a musical work for sale to earn a living. She assisted others to steal. She also broke the law and got caught. She reaped the consequences. -Roger O'Daniel, Minneapolis, MN

Yes. The fundamental premise of American law is the ownership and defense of private property. This includes intellectual property. Taking the property of another without compensation is theft, pure and simple. People seem to be hung up on the "fine" the law levied against the woman at the heart of this story. The fine is excessive and probably unconstitutionally large, but the basic concept is correct - if she stole, she should be punished. Companies spend millions upon millions to create, market, and sell music. Those costs MUST be recouped. Illegal downloads prevent this. It's the same with shoplifting or any other theft. -Michael Corbin, Faribault, MN

Here is the question I always ask: If I take a recipe from a cookbook that I have purchased and post it on a culinary site, or if a newspaper takes a recipe from a cookbook and publishes it for distribution to all of its readers, including those who pick it up in a coffee shop and don't have to pay for it, is that any more or less "moral"? The author of that cookbook is essentially having his or her intellectual property distributed without remuneration. Tell me how that substantively differs from sharing music. The entire Thomas-Rasset case is fatuous. -Ryan McNaughton, St. Paul, MN

Strictly speaking, yes. On the other hand, relentlessly pursuing a housewife demanding millions in lost "potential" sales lacks its own position on the moral high ground. As an artist, I freely give away mp3s of my music, yet I still sell tracks online. Maybe I appeal to a more morally certain crowd, but I think it's because I trust people to make the right decision and don't judge them to be thieves before the fact. -Colin Mansfield, St. Paul, MN

I feel that this is the wrong question to be asking. Instead, we need to look at the morality of how we treat music in our culture; as a product to be capitalized upon rather than an ancient language as universal as smiles or tears. It's only in the past century that people have come to accept the idea that "recording = music". While the immutable medium is a great vehicle for exposure and archival, the true mettle of any musician is live, on stage, not canned in the studio. I would contend that it is in fact immoral to illegalize the sharing of music; it is just another form of performance, at no cost of promotion to the artist or label. -Phillip Knoll, Minneapolis, MN

No, music is meant to be shared. I don't see that much difference between playing a cd I bought at work so my coworkers can hear it and sending an mp3 file to an online buddy. I don't want to cheat artists out of making a living but the record companies have done a very poor job of adapting to technology. -Nicole Masika, Brooklyn Center, MN

Governments make many laws, the violation of which are not moral issues. Music file sharing, while illegal, is not immoral. An argument often used is that sharing music files harms the artist because it deprives the artist of income, but that is not true. ASCAP, BMI, and corporate copyright holders may be deprioved of income, but that begs the question of whether draconian enforcement of licensing benefits the artist. It does not, of course. If such enforcement did benefit the artist we would not see authors and performers self-producing and using the Internet for direct sales, thereby eliminating their corporate "Big Brothers." -Ken Kalish, Park Rapids, MN

In one way in do believe it is immoral. But this is if after listening to a particular artist I do not buy their music and I share this with all of my friends. But if upon listening I decide I like them and buy all of their cd's then I think that it is not an issue. But if I give music to my friends and they never buy any cd's by the artist that would be immoral. After I listen and say I do not like the music I delete it, I do not think of that as immoral. -Randy Peterson, Minneapolis, MN

In most cases, no. Music sharing is probably the best advertisement for the music industry. In fact, through videos posted by other users to youtube (most of them illegally), I have found more new music groups than I can even remember, and they've all made some money from it. I think people should pay for music, but only if they like it! (I pay for my music). On a side note, the amount of money the big labels take from their signed artists is more immoral than illegal music sharing. You want crime, it's the stuff that the big labels do quote "legally"...Music sharing pales in comparison to that. -Michael Stolp-Smith, Rochester, MN

Yes. But that's less important than the fact that it's illegal. -David Evan Thomas, Minneapolis, MN

No it's not immoral. What the RIAA is doing is immoral. For decades the music industry has ripped the consumer off . The music industry is always promoting records by replaying the same 1 or 2 hits off the record. So the consumer hears this, goes out buys the album and soon realizes most the album is shit . The music industry has never refunded the purchase price of a bad record that was purchased because of one good song the radio pushed. And the price of a CD is outrageous. Less than a $1 to make one. It's hardly gone down since it debuted. Now they cry when the consumer gets even through file sharing. Give me a break! -Vince Shane, Inver Grove Heights, MN

I was interviewed following the first trial of Thomas-Rassert, and I explained to the MPR reporter how artists should be able to make a living (i.e. from charging for live shows), but that online filesharing is much like the radio. After I heard myself on the radio, I stopped downloading music through LimeWire -- cold turkey. Something didn't feel right. I wouldn't call it "morality," but I was breaking (albeit outdated) intellectual property laws. Since then, I have discovered how many music CDs are available through the Hennepin County Library, so now I listen to music that is never distributed. My conscience is clear! -Adam Schenck, Richfield, MN

Share your reply in the comments: Is illegally sharing music immoral?

Comment on this post

What's your summer adventure?

Posted at 6:00 AM on July 6, 2009 by Anna Weggel (16 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Economy

Adventure can mean different things to different people. Whether it's traveling to a foreign country, starting a new career, or finding creative ways to have fun in a tough economy, we want to know what the highlight of your summer is going to be this year. What's your summer adventure?

I'm climbing mt Kilimanjaro and a service project to construct a building for an aids orphanage in Tanzania. Not my normal summer. -Matt, St. Paul, MN

Our summer adventure includes driving 13 hours from North Minnesota to St. Louis and keeping two toddlers interested without constant help from DVDs. We plan on many MN and IA school parks. -Aimee Foszpanczyk, Hoyt Lakes, MN

Hiking Isle Royal's Minog Trail. -Brent, Menomonie, WI

In August I will be attending a graduate reunion to celebrate the 80th anniversary of The Seing Eye, this country's first guide dog school. I have worked with 5 Seeing Eye Dogs. -Lolly, Minneapolis, MN

I'm taking my family to Arkansas to dig for diamonds. -Joey E

Going horseback riding in Medora, ND. -Kris, Goodhue, MN

We are going to ride our new recumbent bikes around our beautiful state! -Gae Jarvis

Our summer adventure is to time travel in another country. We will turn our clock back 20 years when we vacation in Upper Michigan mid-August. -Steve, Farmington, MN

I'm going to volunteer at Ojibwe Forest Rally in Bemidji at the end of August when rally competitors from all over the world come to race on our forest roads. -Amy, Motley, MN

Goin' to Jamaica mon and have me some rum punch. Everyting all irie. -Chad, New York, NY (Former St. Louis Park resident)

My summer adventure will be dealing with a blown out disc in my back and no insurance. If you want to feel true loneliness visit the ER and tell them you have no insurance. -Moses

My partner and I will become parents of twin baby girls. Real adventure that goes on and on. -Lisa, St. Paul, MN

Share your reply in the comments: What's your summer adventure?

Comment on this post

What does Independence Day mean to you?

Posted at 12:06 AM on July 3, 2009 by Eric Ringham (7 Comments)
Filed under: Culture, Politics/Government

In 1852 Frederick Douglass asked, "What, to the American slave, is your Fourth of July?" The meaning of the holiday differed then...and surely it differs from one American to another today, depending on perspective and experience. What does Independence Day mean to you?

Independence - it the difference between revolution and revolt. -Corwin, St. Paul, MN

Independence day doesn't mean more to me, than fireworks, family, and bbq. -Mini, Sioux Falls, SD

Independence Day for me represents a spark of the human spirit! -John Leopold, Thief River Falls, MN

I want to feel pride when listening to the declaration of independence but i get held up on the fact that so many of the signers had slaves! -anonymous text message

Independence day, like every national holiday, means time and a half. -anonymous text message

It means that we have to stop bickering for a moment and be thankful for our amazing country and quality of life. -Steph, Minneapolis, MN

Comment on this post