PoliGraph: Fact-checking the GOP presidential debate
Posted at 8:56 PM on September 7, 2011
by Catharine Richert
(7 Comments)
After several weeks of disappointing polling results, the Republican presidential debate was an important moment for Rep. Michele Bachmann.
During the event, Bachmann's rhetoric focused on job creation and the economy. PoliGraph took a look at four of her statements, and found a mixed bag of true, false and misleading claims.
The Claim: The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office said that the new health care law is a job-killer.
The Facts: Bachmann's talking about a CBO report that estimated roughly 800,000 people would leave the workforce to take advantage of new coverage options offered in the health care overhaul that don't require working.
Bachmann gets her number right. But her claim implies that all those people will be fired because of the new law, which is not the case.
PoliGraph said that claim is misleading.
The Claim: The new health care bill took over one-sixth of the American economy.
The Facts: According to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, the health care industry comprises roughly one-sixth of the economy. So, Bachmann's statement implies that the new health care law took over the entire industry.
The Pulitzer Prize winning site PolitiFact gave a similar claim from the Florida Republican Party a Pants on Fire.
PolitiFact sums up its reasoning this way: The plan would expand the government's role in the health care system, but it also would continue to rely on private insurers. Furthermore, for those who can't get coverage, the bill would create a marketplace for people to get private insurance.
Bachmann's claim is false.
The Claim: Bachmann said she was the first person to introduce a repeal of the health care law.
The Facts: The House of Representatives passed the health care law on March 21, 2010.
The following day, Bachmann announced legislation that would eliminate the new law.
Her claim is accurate.
The Claim: Gas was less than $2 a gallon before Obama took office.
The Facts: Recently, Bachmann promised to bring the cost of a gallon of gas below $2 a gallon if she becomes president - roughly the same cost of a gallon of gas in the months before Obama took office.
During the debate, Bachmann again cited that fact, and said she wanted to lower the cost of gas. But she fell short of saying she'd shoot for $2 a gallon. Indeed, her talking point has been criticized for leaving out the important point that gas was cheap in the months leading up to Obama's inauguration because of the recession. Economic activity was at a low point, and as a result, so was fuel consumption.
---
Listen to reporter Catharine Richert discuss Bachmann's claims with MPR's Cathy Wurzer on Morning Edition:
Comments (7)
She makes me embarrassed to be from Minnesota.
Was Bachman debating herself? Why are her "facts" the only ones scrutinized?
You can put a fork in her; she's done. In her defense it is difficult to do well with eight people on stage and the focus on the two front runners. It got late early for Pawlenty and Bachmann.
Pretty sure she isn't going to go much further, we can only hope.. she isn't President material but neither are a lot of the candidates in the Republican Party.
John, PoliGraph only checks Minnesota politicians' statements. Check PoliFact for the rest.
Scared said it right.
It reminds me of when I was in Ireland in late 2003 and people actually shied away from me when I said I was from the US, until I said "I didn't vote for him", then the smiles came back and so did the questions and Guinness.
Bachmann like Sarah is just in it for the $$$, if not why a book?
| September 2011 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
| 1 | 2 | 3 | ||||
| 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 |
| 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 |
| 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | |
Master Archive
Recent Entries
- No legislative pay raise this session
- Lawmakers begin next to last day of session
- Elections and campaign finance bills draw bipartisan support
- Session 2013 in final stretch
- Conference committee agrees to spend $485 million more for schools, early ed
- Water fees dropped from environment budget bill
- Mayo DMC plan is moving
- Gas tax hike and sales tax for transit get scrapped
- House approves legislator pay constitutional amendment
- Republicans try to make issue of IRS PAC contributions
Categories
- 2011 Freshman class
- 2011 Shutdown
- Bachmann fact check
- Campaign 2008
- Campaign 2008: MN Legislature
- Campaign 2008: President
- Campaign 2008: U.S. MN CD1
- Campaign 2008: U.S. MN CD2
- Campaign 2008: U.S. MN CD3
- Campaign 2008: U.S. MN CD4
- Campaign 2008: U.S. MN CD5
- Campaign 2008: U.S. MN CD6
- Campaign 2008: U.S. Senate
- Campaign 2010
- Campaign 2010: Minnesota Governor
- Campaign 2010: U.S. House
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD1
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD2
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD3
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD4
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD5
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD6
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD7
- Campaign 2010: U.S. MN CD8
- Campaign 2012
- Campaign 2012: Minn. House Races
- Campaign 2012: Minn. Senate Races
- Campaign 2012: Presidential Race
- Campaign 2012: U.S. House
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD1
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD2
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD3
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD4
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD5
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD6
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD7
- Campaign 2012: U.S. MN CD8
- Campaign 2012: U.S. Senate
- Daily Digest
- Iowa
- Mark Dayton
- Marriage Amendment
- Michele Bachmann
- MN Legislature
- MPR in D.C.
- Pawlenty fact check
- Pawlenty travel
- PoliGraph
- Political parties
- Recount
- Recount 2010
- Redistricting
- State Government
- Tim Pawlenty
- U.S. House
- U.S. Senate
- Vikings stadium
- Voter ID Amendment
About Poligraph
The feature examines statements made by Minnesota politicians and checks them for accuracy. Based on data analysis, document reviews and interviews with non-partisan analysts, statements are rated true, misleading, false or inconclusive. MoreServices
- Become a Member
- Member Connect Accounts
- Leadership Circle
- Sustaining Members
- Member Discounts
- Become a Sponsor
- Tax Information
- Planned Giving
- Vehicle Donation
- Donate Stock