![]() |
News Cut Category Archive: Science
Questions and answers about the salmonella outbreak and flu
Posted at 10:59 AM on January 9, 2009
by Bob Collins
(5 Comments)
Filed under: Health, Science
Michael Osterholm, the former Minnesota state epidemiologist and now director of the , the University of Minnesota Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy is on MPR's Midday (Listen here), discussion the nationwide salmonella outbreak.
I'm live-blogging the pertinent questions and answers. He's also talking about other issues facing health investigators. The other big health story today is the word that Tamiflu may not be effective on this year's strain.
Osterholm says there's actually three strains of flu that float around the world, one of which was an "escapee" from a Russian lab years ago.
Q: Why isn't Tamiflu working?
A: The strain changed in a way that makes it resistant to the flu. The good news is (a) the change may not stay. Next year's strain may lose the resistance, and (b) this year "we have a great match on the vaccine with the strain that's in Minnesota.
Q: Has the possibility of a pandemic or bird flu changed?
A: We're closer to a pandemic today than we were yesterday. When people say "if it were to happen it would've happened by now, H3N8 strain jumped from birds to horses in the 1960s and we have no idea why. The same strain then jumped to dogs and we're seeing problems with dogs. We know little about influenza.
Q: Why are we just hearing about the salmonella outbreak now?
A: The first cases occurred in early October. This has been gaining a head of steam with most cases occurring in the last six weeks. This is a common strain of salmonella. We have the ability to fingerprint the organisms. It took time for the "fingerprints" to be obtained. It has increased in the number of states which tells us a lot about the product involved. It's probably a store-shelf product.
The cases in Minnesota are more recent nature. It's likely that the Minnesota Department of Public Health will be the one to crack it.
Q: Has something changed in the food environment?
A: Even a loaf of Sara Lee bread, the ingredients are likely from 10 different countries. It's remarkably how safe food really is, given how much food we eat. The average person has two food-borne illnesses a year. But we have so many more processes than we had before.
Q: Is food illness more insidious?
A: Think of all the food that you don't cook. Even the things you do cook, there are things you don't cook adequately. Part of the problem is some contamination occurs in plants (such as deli meats) after the cooking process.
Q: When the CDC investigated the "tomato outbreak" (which turned out to be wrong), does the CDC get gunshy about publicizing an investigation?
A: You're right, but having been at the Minnesota Department of Public Health as long as I was, Minnesota doesn't get it wrong and they get it quickly often. When the first outbreak of Salmonella St. Paul was identified in Minnesota, they identified it quickly that it wasn't tomatoes, it was peppers. Had the other states been half as competent as Minnesota, it could've been picked up much earlier.
Osterholm says he's worried the Health Department will "take a hit" in the coming budget cuts.
Q: Is there a fear that publicizing these things too early will hurt industry?
A: Yes, but I don't think that's the case here. Once the number of cases grew here quickly, they (the MDH) jumped on it. I wouldn't be surprised to see this solved in just a couple of days.
Listener questions
Q: What advice would you give to Obama?
A: Osterholm says he's working with the Obama transition team on who to bring in. "I'm excited about the interest in solid science," he said. As a world, we are going to have to take major cuts in programs. What I worry about is public health, which is only 1% of the budget and much of that funding is in jeopardy right now. If you cut out some basic public health programs, you'll pay more down the road. If the pandemic flu hits tomorrow, it'll make everything else seem like child's play.
Q: Should people have faith in federal health agencies?
A: I was critical of the CDC in the tomato vs. peppers outbreak, but I also saw the CDC do a great job overall. Is some of it a problem? Absolutely. But it's unfortunate that people label everything dark or light or right or wrong.
Q: What do you think of Sanjay Gupta as surgeon general?
A: He's a friend and his knowledge is exceptional. He'd make a great surgeon general. Having known past surgeon generals, the office has been "dumbed down." The Obama administration wants to restore that to a very strong voice to the world. There's very few health communicators out there than Sanjay Gupta. He's an actively practicing physician. Every Monday morning he scrubs in and does some amazing brain surgery.
Q: What is the health impact of people coming across the border from the south?
A: At Hennpin County Medical Center, they needed to have 65 interpreters to provide health care. Of 65 6.2 billion on the face of the earth, 2 billion have TB. We want to make sure we deal with the populations from their health perspective. We don't want it to spread to others and that's where I get people's concern about people coming in from other countries... there's been very limited transmission of disease to other groups. We see it within their own family. We shouldn't use it as a wedge issue to say "they shouldn't be here."
Q: Why is Minnesota better than other states at finding the answers to food-borne illnesses?
A: In 1965, we had three people who worked in infectious diseases. Over the years we built the group up through outside resources -- research money, grant money -- and since the early '80s, the MDPH has had an ethic of excellence where some of the top people in the country have been trained and have stayed. We have people at the U who are on call all of the time. We can do some testing in three days that takes the state of Texas 6 weeks. Our laboratory is one of the best -- if not the best -- in the country. There's been a sense of excellence that has stayed and we're lucky to live in a state that values that.
Salmonella outbreak started months ago
Posted at 9:01 AM on January 9, 2009
by Bob Collins
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Science
Yesterday, the Centers for Disease Control confirmed to the Associated Press that, indeed, a salmonella outbreak is racing across the country, puzzling health officials over its source. It sounds like something that just happened, doesn't it? But, no, it started in September, and most of the people got sick after December 1.
After the Associated Press story from the Centers for Disease Control hit the Internet, the Minnesota Department of Public Health confirmed that 30 people in Minnesota have gotten sick from salmonella and one 70-year-old woman with other underlying health conditions has died.
Health officials across the country are scrambling to talk to people who've been affected, hoping to be able to connect the victims to a common source .
But at least in Massachusetts, health officials have been slow on the uptake. One 7-year-old girl was affected just before Thanksgiving, spent 4 days in the hospital, and her mother is upset that health officials still have not contacted the family.
Presumably, the states have known about the outbreak, but until the Associated Press story, there was no public announcement of it. Anywhere. As of this morning, there is still nothing on the Minnesota Department of Public Health Web site about the outbreak, although there is valuable information there .
"It is often difficult to identify sources of foodborne outbreaks. People may not remember the foods they recently ate and may not be aware of all of the ingredients in food. That's what makes these types of investigations very difficult," according to CDC spokesman David Daigle.
Says the CDC's update:
"In outbreaks like this one, identification of the contaminated product requires conducting detailed standardized interviews with persons who were ill and with non-ill members of the public ("controls") to compare foods they recently ate and other exposures," the CDC's update says. "Using statistical methods, the contaminated item is identified as one to which significantly more ill persons than controls were exposed. ... The investigation is labor intensive and typically takes weeks. It is not always successful."
Scientific American says there may be good reason why news of an outbreak that started last fall is just now being made public.
The agency's disease trackers, who were criticized for taking three months to trace another large salmonella outbreak last spring to Mexican Serrano peppers, haven't determined the latest outbreak's origin. They mistakenly blamed tomatoes for last year's scourge, costing growers $100 million in sales.
Meanwhile, the University of Minnesota Center for Infectious Disease Research and Policy says an initial suggestion that chicken may be a cause is not correct:
An online newspaper report yesterday that said the CDC had activated its emergency network to investigate the outbreak was incorrect, CDC spokeswoman Lola Russell told CIDRAP News today. She also said a report that chicken was suspected as the source of the outbreak was wrong.
"We're not in emergency status with this," Russell said. As for the source, she added, "We don't know what it is yet. It would be very premature to indicate that it's chicken or anything else."
The Center's director, former state epidemiologist Mike Osterholm will be on MPR's Midday at 11 to discuss the outbreak.
What's love got to do with it?
Posted at 3:03 PM on January 7, 2009
by Bob Collins
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Science
An Emory University professor, Larry Young, writes in the journal Nature that love involves a series of neurochemical events that happen in a specific part of the brain.
If true, one will no longer need oysters, chocolates, or even cheap wine and some Barry White to create "a loving mood," as the BBC calls it.
Under Young's theory, scientists, some of whom can't currently get a date, could create chemicals that would make people fall in love with the first person they see, or even refall in love with someone.
"It may actually enhance our ability to form relationships, and so it is a very real possibility that something like oxytocin could be used in conjunction with marital therapies to bring back that spark," he says.
In the future, you may have to take a pill to stay married.
The power of the pinhole
Posted at 6:39 PM on January 6, 2009
by Bob Collins
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Science
Reader Derek Schille writes, "For whatever reason this screamed news cut to me."

It's a six-month time-lapse image of a bridge, taken with a pinhole camera. The lines are the travels of the sun in relation to the planet.
One giant leap for biofuels
Posted at 9:17 AM on December 31, 2008
by Bob Collins
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Science
In a slow news week, this should've gotten bigger play.
Fuel from the weed jatropha powered an Air New Zealand jet on a two-hour flight today--the world's second flight of a commercial jet on biofuel. One out of the four Rolls Royce engines on an Air New Zealand Boeing 747-400 burned a 50-50 blend of regular jet fuel and a bio-version made from jatropha.
The flight more than doubled the air time of the first biofuel flight--a 40 minute jaunt between London and Amsterdam in February. The plane climbed to an altitude of 35,000 feet and the engine performed normally, according to chief pilot Capt. David Morgan.
Details are in Scientific American.
Of course there remains a big problem:
Biofuels don't contain the oil necessary to help seals and rings in engines swell. So the lief of an aircraft engine would be reduced. That's a big deal. The GE engine on a 777 could go for as high as $10 million apiece.
This issue is playing out in all forms of aviation, including general aviation. I have this thing sitting in a hangar -- a new airplane engine.

It runs on fully leaded gasoline, which is being phased out. It may be a huge paperweight in a short period of time. These engines can run on auto fuel, but Minnesota's ethanol content will rot the seals and reduce its life.
Researchers are trying to solve problems like this but so far there doesn't appear to be a solution. Most of the small airplanes you see in the air are flying on borrowed time.
Not ready for prime time
Posted at 1:40 PM on December 30, 2008
by Bob Collins
(0 Comments)
Filed under: Science
The Israeli consulate is holding a "press conference" via Twitter this afternoon in what surely is a first. People post messages with the @israelconsulate address in the message.
The format has a way to go before it becomes valuable, however. Unlike most press conferences, with this one you have to read the answers first and then work your way back to find out the questions.
However, the "answers" so far, make the questions as obvious as the answers are predictable.
Here are some of the major points highlighted so far (with the actual answers):
A better way to follow things is by searching #AskIsrael, but then you have to read through miles of posts of people writing, "I'm typing up a question to ask the Israeli consulate."

Sometimes, the old media is a better forum. If there's one issue that can't be explained in a series of 140 character messages, this one is it.
It was a nice try, however.
The longest day
Posted at 7:35 AM on December 29, 2008
by Bob Collins
(1 Comments)
Filed under: Science
Apparently, I don't have enough to worry about. The economy stinks. The Wild look like an expansion team. I don't remember how to drive on dry pavement.
Now this: The earth is slowing down. It's gotten so slow that the Department of Time is going to add a second to 2008, which has already been acting like the drunken relative who didn't know when to leave.
The second will be added on Wednesday at 5:59:59 p.m.
According to the experts, the earth is slowing because of the braking action of tides, snow or the lack of it at the polar ice caps, solar wind, space dust and magnetic storms, although I've always suspected the Foshay Tower was somewhat responsible.
At the present rate, it'll be billions of years before the earth stops rotating -- around the time the Minnesota U.S. Senate recount ends -- and inhabitants of Planet Earth engage in the interstellar version of Wheel of Fortune.
Alzheimer's
Posted at 11:02 AM on December 26, 2008
by Bob Collins
(1 Comments)
Filed under: Health, Science
Ten million of us baby boomers are going to develop Alzheimer's. Expect coverage of research to increase. Let's begin with this one that's out today.
At Northeastern University in Boston, researchers say the disease may get its start by an insufficient blood flow carrying sugar to the brain. They suggest that exercise -- now -- may be the answer.
Meanwhile, a researcher at McGill University is out with a study today that says patients who frequently kick or cry out in their sleep may be at an increased risk of developing a neurodegenerative disease, such as Alzheimer's or Parkinson's.
There's no simple test for Alzheimer's. The Alzheimer's Foundation of America is suggesting a five-minute test, which others say is hugely controversial. Why? Take it and see if you can figure it out:
Tell someone three random words: car, pencil, banana. Then have the person draw a clock with the correct time, as a distraction. A little later, can he or she recall the words?
As a Chicago Tribune article pointed out, "Failing such a test doesn't mean someone has dementia. But it signals there might be a problem with short-term memory that should be checked by a doctor. Maybe it's something fixable, such as depression or thyroid disease. Maybe it is an Alzheimer's warning sign. Or maybe the person just isn't a good test taker."
The final frontier
Posted at 9:29 AM on December 12, 2008
by Than Tibbetts
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Politics, Science
Everything about being the incoming administration is tough, and President-elect Barack Obama will have no shortage of tough decisions about science policy.
The Orlando Sentinel reports that NASA is already digging a moat, lifting up the drawbridge and preparing for a siege.
NASA administrator Mike Griffin is not cooperating with President-elect Barack Obama's transition team, is obstructing its efforts to get information and has told its leader that she is "not qualified" to judge his rocket program, the Orlando Sentinel has learned....
Griffin's resistance is part of a no-holds-barred effort to preserve the Constellation program, the delayed and over-budget moon rocket that is his signature project.
NASA's budget is small potatoes compared to some recent government programs — at around $17 billion is only about 40 times smaller than the $700 billion Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008. But, it sets up an interesting question.
Are the programs worthy scientific endeavors, a critical pseudo-extension of our national security and national pride into the great beyond and a extension of the infrastructure the Obama administration says should be invested in?
Or are they an overindulging slate of geek hubris, a chronically over-budget and poor investment when money would be better spent on more terrestrial matters?
NASA has had its share of successes and failure, and a higher failure rate is probably more tolerable when working at the extreme limits of human exploration and knowledge. And while President Bush laid out his Vision for Space Exploration plan in 2004 with ambitious goals of returning humans to the moon by 2020 and putting people on Mars shortly (in NASA terms) after that, the burden will be on Obama to determine what is a worthy investment and what's a waste of money.
My guess is that greeting the transition team with a mix of confrontation and paranoia isn't going to help your chances in preserving your programs.
Soon after, [Obama space transition team head Lori] Garver and Griffin engaged in what witnesses said was an animated conversation. Some overheard parts of it."Mike, I don't understand what the problem is. We are just trying to look under the hood," Garver said.
"If you are looking under the hood, then you are calling me a liar," Griffin replied. "Because it means you don't trust what I say is under the hood."
Aside: If you've ever wondered about the breathtaking scope of the U.S. federal budget, spend your coffee break looking over this massive interactive graphic.
The conjunction
Posted at 5:53 PM on December 1, 2008
by Bob Collins
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Science

We've got a conjunction up there. Venus, Jupiter and the Moon are all near each other as viewed from terra firma, creating a "frown," as National Geographic puts it. But in the above picture from Kenya, it looks more like a smile.
We haven't done this since the the eclipse months ago (Good grief, it was February! Was it really February? It seems like only recently.) and I probably should've asked earlier today but if you take a picture, send it to me and I'll post it.
Update 7:23 p.m. Just took this from the runway at South St. Paul airport. Lame camera, though. And ignore Flight 837 from wherever.

The conjunction is not only a frown, but appears to be crying, in this picture from Sharon Stiteler. It's actually quite Van Gogh-like.

Just one more thing to worry about
Posted at 5:38 PM on November 25, 2008
by Bob Collins
(2 Comments)
Filed under: Science
The Current's Mary Lucia and I were chatting a bit ago about what we would do if we learned an asteroid was heading for earth. Today, a conference got underway in Vienna to try to set up a global plan for diverting an asteroid heading for earth's midsection.
Mary said "at least it will be quick." But maybe not. Theoretically, according to experts, it should be possible to determine 15 years ahead of time that an asteroid is heading our way. Fifteen years. In fact, there's one roaming around around out there right now, experts say, that could hit us in 2029 if it goes through a small "keyhole" of space enough to deflect its orbit right into us.
I'll be 75 then, and not terribly concerned, although it may make me rethink the whole "long term" strategy for dealing with the stock market.
Oh, one of Mary's many listeners sent this video in which has nothing to do with asteroids but must've been frightening on its own. It happened in Edmonton last week and was captured by a dashboard camera on a police car. (link fixed)
You have to give credit to a cop who doesn't even slow down while driving toward a fireball from space that sure seemed as if it was heading straight for him.
From toilet to tap
Posted at 1:02 PM on November 25, 2008
by Bob Collins
(4 Comments)
Filed under: Science
There are some headlines you just can't ignore.
Like this one from the BBC today.
Nasa jubilant at urine solution
If you haven't been following this closely, NASA is testing a system of providing drinking water to astronauts that is filtered from their urine. And if you have been following this closely, well, don't tell me you haven't been thinking about this because I know you have.
"Not to spoil anything, but I think up here the appropriate words are 'Yippee!'," space station Commander Mike Fincke told mission control early on Tuesday morning.
He supervised work on the malfunctioning water regeneration system - which distils, filters, ionises and oxidises wastewater including urine, perspiration and bath water, into drinkable water.
Nobody's taking a swig of anything yet. The sampled brew will be tested by NASA when the astronauts return. But let's be indelicate here for just a moment in the interest of science. Suppose this thing works, and the thing spits out lovely drinking water in bottles that say "Pluto Springs." What if at some point in the future, it breaks again. How will they know?
This concept is not limited to space. More and more communities are considering tapping their sewage treatment plants as a source of drinking water.
In California, a plant is already working, as described by the New York Times in an August article:
When you flush in Santa Ana, the waste makes its way to the sewage-treatment plant nearby in Fountain Valley, then sluices not to the ocean but to a plant that superfilters the liquid until it is cleaner than rainwater. The "new" water is then pumped 13 miles north and discharged into a small lake, where it percolates into the earth. Local utilities pump water from this aquifer and deliver it to the sinks and showers of 2.3 million customers. It is now drinking water. If you like the idea, you call it indirect potable reuse. If the idea revolts you, you call it toilet to tap.
The cold facts
Posted at 1:48 PM on October 28, 2008
by Bob Collins
(1 Comments)
Filed under: Health, Science
File this in the "news you'd hear if it weren't for politics" file.
At a conference on infectious diseases today, University of Virginia researchers released a study of the common places where people pick up colds.
The researchers started with 30 adults with early symptoms of colds and retraced the things they touched in the previous 18 hours, using DNA tests to hunt for rhinovirus, which causes about half of all colds.
"We found that commonly touched areas like refrigerator doors and handles were positive about 40 percent of the time" for cold germs, said Dr. Birgit Winther, an ear, nose and throat specialist who helped conduct the study.
The culprits:
The researchers also figured out that a person touching these items could catch the cold virus even if it had been 48 hours since the person transmitting the cold had touched them. This, apparently, is not true for the flu virus.
Why can't we cure the common cold? The Buffalo News has a sensational article analyzing that today. The short answer? There's too many viruses. Another answer: Viruses are smarter than we are. For example, the reason a cold isn't more severe than it is is because the virus needs you to walk around infecting other people
Scotch Tape science
Posted at 10:23 AM on October 23, 2008
by Bob Collins
(5 Comments)
Filed under: Science
On one of yesterday's visits with Mary Lucia on the Current, I mentioned the finding that under the right circumstances, you could use a roll of Scotch Tape to make an X-Ray.
Here's the story on Nature News.
As long ago as 1953, a team of scientists based in Russia suggested that peeling sticky tape produced X-rays. But "we were very sceptical about the old results," says Escobar (the researcher). His team decided to look into the phenomenon anyway, and found that X-rays were indeed given off, in high-energy pulses.
When the researchers placed a small plastic window in their vacuum chamber, they were even able to take an X-ray image of a finger, using a dental X-ray detector. Their results are published in Nature.
What can science do with this newfound knowledge? "The researchers suggest that the high charge density generated by peeling the tape could be great enough to trigger nuclear fusion," the article said.
Mining the moon
Posted at 11:07 AM on October 22, 2008
by Bob Collins
(2 Comments)
Filed under: Science

India's planned spaceshot to the Moon is an easy one to ignore -- it's just another country not named the United States ramping up its space program while the only country to actually land and walk on the moon seems increasingly content to keep its feet on terra firma.
"When completed, this mission will put India in the very small group of six countries which have thus far sent space missions to the moon," said Krishnaswamy Kasturirangan, a member of the Indian parliament, reinforcing the narrative that this is about prestige and a place at the scientific table.
And maybe it is. But tucked into the New York Times story today is this nugget:
The Indian mission is scheduled to last two years, prepare a three-dimensional atlas of the moon and prospect the lunar surface for natural resources, including uranium, a coveted fuel for nuclear power plants, according to the Indian Space Research Organization.
The moon as strip mine? It's not that far fetched. A 2004 Popular Mechanics article from former astronaut Harrison Schmitt.
It is not a lack of engineering skill that prevents us from using helium-3 to meet our energy needs, but a lack of the isotope itself. Vast quantities of helium originate in the sun, a small part of which is helium-3, rather than the more common helium-4. Both types of helium are transformed as they travel toward Earth as part of the solar wind. The precious isotope never arrives because Earth's magnetic field pushes it away. Fortunately, the conditions that make helium-3 rare on Earth are absent on the moon, where it has accumulated on the surface and been mixed with the debris layer of dust and rock, or regolith, by constant meteor strikes. And there it waits for the taking.
Science: What if?
Posted at 7:33 AM on October 16, 2008
by Bob Collins
(1 Comments)
Filed under: Health, Science
It's always a bad idea to get too far ahead where medical research is concerned, but it's hard not to play "what if" with a science story being reported now.
Researchers have found monkeys, taught to play a computer game, can regain use of paralyzed muscles and even learned to use muscles that previously had nothing to do with wrist movement.
The significance? According to the Associated Press:
Remarkably, the monkeys regained use of paralyzed muscles by learning to control the activity of just a single brain cell.
The result is "an important step forward," said Dawn Taylor of Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, who studies the concept of using brain signals to overcome paralysis. She wasn't involved in the new work.
The tipping point
Posted at 6:34 PM on September 28, 2008
by Bob Collins
(3 Comments)
Filed under: Science
Here's a new video that's recently been uploaded explaining climate change and, more precisely, a recalculation of the "tippping point."
Wake Up, Freak Out - then Get a Grip from Leo Murray on Vimeo.
The script is posted here. The author says the answer is to consume less, which is never going to happen, at least in my lifetime.
Archives
January 2009 | ||||||
SU |
MO |
TU |
WE |
TH |
FR |
SA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | ||||
| 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 |
| 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 |
| 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |
Recent Entries
- Minnesota health agency cracks salmonella mystery
- The week-in-review quiz
- How to survive at work when everyone else is getting laid off
- Questions and answers about the salmonella outbreak and flu
- Salmonella outbreak started months ago
- The last-minute nation
- What happens when the cameras stop rolling?
- Are the mayors dreaming of being governor?
- Graduation day
- Salmonella outbreak
Categories
- Arts
- Bridges and roads
- Crime and Justice
- Disasters
- Economy
- Energy
- Health
- Icons
- Life
- Marketing and advertising
- Media
- News
- Northwest Airlines
- Pawlenty
- Politics
- Regional history
- Religion
- Schools
- Science
- Sports
- Surveys and trivia
- Tech
- The jobs we do
- The political conventions
- The Quiz
- Things that are puzzling
- War
- Weather








