The politics of mental health (5X8 - 2/7/13)
Posted at 7:22 AM on February 7, 2013
by Bob Collins
(13 Comments)
Filed under: Five by 8
The risk and the reward, Minnesota's same-sex marriage debate, the false memories we hold dear, a hero loses his medal in Duluth, and why do people link weather and climate change?
The push for greater gun control and help for those with mental illness have been joined at the hip in the wake of the tragedy in Connecticut. Is that changing America's view of people with mental illness? It's an unanswerable question at the moment, just one to think about. But it provides a glimpse into the reality of politics: You can't always get what you want.
It's undeniable that millions of Americans suffer from a mental illness, almost none of them are threats of undertaking a mass shooting, and few politicians were particularly concerned enough to consider the situation urgent. Case in point? As the Star Tribune reported, the Obama administration has dragged its feet on implementing the mental health parity law, which passed five years ago.
But check the headlines this week. Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker has announced plans to spend $29 million more on mental health services. "We recognize that the current system for treating those with mental illness simply isn't getting the job done," Republican Assembly Speaker Robin Vos said.
How did Walker and his Assembly colleagues come to recognize that? Connecticut.
In Virginia this week, 15 Fairfax County employees began a course in mental health first aid because local government workers are more likely to encounter people in need of mental health services, according to the Washington Post. What prompted the program? The shooting of Gabby Giffords.
In Minnesota Sen. Kevin Dahle has submitted legislation to identify the early warning signs of mental illness in children and adolescents, and requires schools to be smarter about understanding mental illness among students. He noted -- correctly, of course -- that the recent attention to the issue -- that is: Connecticut -- should lead to a long-term solution.
Mental health advocates have been calling for many of these things for years; their calls usually fell on deaf ears until nearly two dozen school children were slaughtered. Those advocates are in a difficult situation. The atmosphere is right for their proposals to advance. But doing so has been linked to a fear of the mentally ill, possibly reversing decades of efforts at understanding.
Four more gun bills are up for discussion in a committee at the Capitol today.
Related: Smoking, once encouraged for people with mental illness, now may be banned in some hospitals. (NY Times)
2) THE SAME-SEX MARRIAGE DEBATE BEGINS AGAIN
Though most of last night's State of the State address revolved around the economy, it was Gov. Dayton's call for the legalization of same-sex marriage last night that might have set the tone for the rest of the legislative session.
Supporters are buoyed by last year's rejection of an amendment to the state constitution banning same-sex marriage. A new poll, however, suggests that not everyone voting against the measure was voting for same-sex marriage.
In the KSTP poll, 54% said the law defining marriage as between one man and one woman should be left as it is, while 42% said it should be changed.
But a year ago this week, a KSTP poll on the marriage amendment showed a 47-to-39 percent split in favor of banning same-sex marriage. In the election, however, 51% voted against the amendment.
Related: The Boy Scouts have delayed a decision on whether to lift a ban on gay members. The Scouts are closely aligned with many churches, churches that disagree with the idea of homosexuality.
When last many of us saw Zach Wahls of Iowa, he was giving this speech to the Iowa House Judiciary Committee in 2011 as it debated same-sex marriage.
It turns out he's an Eagle Scout and last night debated a church leader in an unusually spirited debate for public broadcasting.
Related: A legally married same-sex couple in Fargo has been denied a family golf pass. (Fargo Forum)
3) THE FALSE MEMORIES WE HOLD DEAR
It is startlingly easy to create false memories, especially in politics, Freakonomics Radio's Stephen J. Dubner says.
4) BUT YOU CAN'T STEAL HEROISM
A Duluth man, who received a medal for saving victims of a plane crash in Duluth years ago, received a medal for his heroism. It contained this description:
"Observing that the victim did not respond to a ring buoy thrown in her direction and appeared lifeless as she sank beneath the surface of the water, Mr. Halverson immediately secured a line and dived 40 feet into the turbulent water to assist the victim. Although hampered by difficulty in breathing, he courageously swam through the debris-filled and chilly 52-degree water to the survivor, reaching her just as she was submerging again. Feeling the debilitating effect of his immersion in the cold water and unable to speak, Mr. Halverson supported the victim, swam with her to a buoy thrown from his ship, and clung there until arrival of a Coast Guard boat to assist in the rescue."
The medal has been stolen, the Duluth News Tribune reports, and the man wonders why the store at which it was pawned -- The Gold Guys -- didn't adequately question where it came from.
5) BACK-PEDALING ON CLIMATE CHANGE
A big storm is heading for the northeast and may leave up to three feet of snow. Will this change people's opinion on a warming planet? Weather and climate are two different things, but new research shows that people aren't accepting that.
The BBC says fewer people now believe the planet is warming and they're basing that on the weather.
And, one researcher says, those who support the idea of climate change are quick to ignore the distinction between climate and weather when it's convenient to do so.
"We go on offense during a heat wave and then we lie low the rest of the time and don't talk about it," he says. "During a cold spell, the only time you hear from climate scientists in the newspapers is when we are refuting things - we need to be consistent and talk about this regardless of the weather."
Related: What part of "don't drive on Lake Minnetonka's ice" don't people get?" All of it, apparently.
Image: Steve Erdahl
This happened on Tuesday, MPR's Paul Huttner says. And he says 15 vehicles have gone through the ice on his lake in the last few weeks.
Bonus I: Today, the crew of the space station will be holding a conversation with William Shatner. It's a follow-up to the greatest Twitter conversation in the history of the galaxy.
Bonus II: How serious is the competition between media in Fargo? Photoshop serious, apparently. (Fargo Forum)
Bonus III: The poor farmers. It's not their fault the marketers in the city used them to sell trucks.
Bonus IV: How many books can you read in a year? Twin Citian Kevin Hendricks read 137.
TODAY'S QUESTION
The Minnesota Idea Open and the St. Paul Foundation are sponsoring a competition to find the best idea for revitalizing St. Paul, and they will award $1 million toward implementing it. Today's Question: If you could have $1 million to improve your community, what would you do with it?
WHAT WE'RE DOING
Daily Circuit (9-12 p.m.) - First hour: Rabbi Harold Kushner on a question he's been pondering for more than thirty years: What kind of God permits bad things to happen to good people? (Rebroadcast)
Second hour: Local faith leaders Bishop Peter Rogness, Imam Makram El-Amin, and Rabbi Staci Offner. (Rebroadcast)
Third hour: Religion scholar Chris Stedman talks about his new book, Faitheist, which draws on his own unique religious experiences and academic studies to explain why it's necessary to bridge the growing divide between atheists and religious adherents. (Rebroadcast)
MPR News Presents (12-1 pm): A live Westminster Town Hall Forum with former VP Al Gore.
Talk of the Nation (1-2 p.m.) - As President Obama's pick to lead the CIA heads up to Capitol Hill for his confirmation hearing, a Justice Department memo leaked that justifies the extrajudicial execution of American citizens if they're terrorists. NPR considers drones, waterboarding, and the CIA.
All Things Considered (3-6:30 p.m.) - In a new movie about teenage romance, the leading man has trouble being himself and talking to girls. He's a zombie. NPR will "report" on the striking similarities between zombies and love-struck teens.
Comments (13)
Thank you Bob for including the Funny or Die "Farmers" video. It made me laugh and I needed that today.
When I watched that Super Bowl Farmer's commercial, my mind went to the same place. Farmers are not what they used to be and it is controlled by big corporations and Monsanto, etc.
How many Americans really realize that?
Bonus IV: How many books can you read in a year? Twin Citian Kevin Hendricks read 137.
Wimp. My wife read 178 in 2012, ~150 in 2011, around ~120 in 2010 the year she started tracking.
Well, in a way, this kind of proves my point. My post was about access to service for people with mental illness. The response was about guns. As if they're the same issue.
BJ: Yes, there are some amazing people who have read lots more than 137 books! My little booklet includes an interview with a friend who read 175. So it's not about the number--it's about loving to read.
137 is just a fun number that gets people's attention. But I totally realize as bragging it doesn't work. ;-)
Thanks for the nod, Bob!
Oh, and I should probably mention that the Kindle version of my little booklet, 137 Books in One Year, is free today.
I think it's part of human nature to avoid dealing with large, complex issues until something happens so that we can no longer ignore the problem. We tend to turn a blind eye to problems or don't even think about a potential problem until disaster strikes. How many people were concerned with the availability of life boats until Titanic? The Secret Service wasn't created until a couple of Presidents had been assassinated. Cassandra was mocked, after all, and not much has changed since.
It would be nice if our suicide rate was enough to get the public concerned with mental health, but that number isn't viewed as a national tragedy on the same scale as a school shooting is. Unfortunately, we just don't seem to work that way.
SurveyUSA has a poor track record in Minnesota. Take that poll with a metric tonne of salt.
A poll 9 months before an election that doesn't match final results doesn't mean the poll was inaccurate at all. It could very well signal that a shift in sentiment took place during the course of the marriage amendment campaign, something that is confirmed by the fast the last Survey USA poll was within the margin of error.
I tend to defer to David Brauer on matters of local polls. He tends to follow them more than i do. He said last year that Survey USA has a strong record locally.
//Kevin D. Hendricks
I sometimes get a little snarky here - my 12 books last year are no where close to your number.
BJ: No worries, you made fair comments. That's why I included the interview with a friend who read more books than me. Knocks down any bravado I might be trying to put up.
It's all good.
SurveyUSA was demonstratably dead-wrong on the amendment polling. They greatly underpolled the "no" vote, while others like SCSU and PPP were much closer to the real outcome, especially late in the game.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minnesota_Amendment_1
The only time you CAN judge the accuracy of a poll is "late in the game."
PPP hasn't had the strongest track record in MN. I would have to look at state but nationally Survey USA has had a strong rating the last 3-4 congressional cycles. If I recall PPP had Jim Oberstar winning by around 20% in 2010. St Cloud has been off a little since 2004 if I recall, over sampling DFL.
PS are we already back to arguing about polls.
PPS I like the recorded touch tone style the Survey USA does, I think in this day and age we are getting real answers when people feel it is anonymous.
| February 2013 | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S | M | T | W | T | F | S |
| 1 | 2 | |||||
| 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 |
| 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 |
| 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 |
| 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | ||
Master Archive
Recent Entries
- The crowdsourced vacation
- 'Phone tapping' is the new birth certificate
- Bad week. Good people
- Military moms and the bond they have
- Bob Dylan's world
- The stuff we throw away (5x8 - 5/24/13)
- Sunday liquor sales: The little bill that can't
- The concealed carry muzzle
- There's Texas and then there's everywhere else
- Tornado damage via satellite
Categories
- Arts
- Aviation
- Crime and Justice
- Disasters
- Economy
- Energy
- Five by 8
- Floods
- Floods 2011
- Health
- History
- Icons
- Life
- Marketing and advertising
- Mary and Bob
- Media
- News
- People doing good
- Politics
- Race
- Regional history
- Religion
- Schools
- Science
- Sports
- Surveys and trivia
- Tech
- The jobs we do
- War
- Weather
- You Should Meet...
Services
- Become a Member
- Member Connect Accounts
- Leadership Circle
- Sustaining Members
- Member Discounts
- Become a Sponsor
- Tax Information
- Planned Giving
- Vehicle Donation
- Donate Stock