News Cut: November 2, 2011 Archive

The solution in search of a problem

Posted at 11:55 AM on November 2, 2011 by Bob Collins (7 Comments)
Filed under: Aviation

Thanks to this newly-posted Ted Talk video (sent to me by my pal, Michael Wells), the infatuation with an airplane you can drive like a car is back in the news.

As a pilot, I've always found the Terrafugia to be interesting, but once you get past the "isn't it interesting?" what are you left with? I thought the idea would die before it ever came to fruition, just as every other similar idea has died. But next year, the company will start selling them.

If someone in Minnesota, for example, should buy one of these, state officials will have to get together and decide whether this is a car or a plane.

The definition is significant. It'll probably be an airplane, which means you'd have to pay a registration tax of 1 percent of its list price, which is expected to be about $279,000. Compare that $2,790 to the price you pay for your car's license tabs.

When you're driving it as a car, is it a car or an airplane? Are you covered by your auto insurance or your aircraft insurance? Minnesota laws require $100,000 of coverage for each person in the aircraft (it's a two-seat plane) and $300,000 for bodily injury per occurrence.

For auto insurance, Minnesota requires only $60,000 of coverage for injury liability for two or more people.

Would you need to buy both an auto insurance policy and an aircraft insurance policy? There's no savings in that. I pay $900 a year for insurance now for an airplane project that's not flying. That will probably go to more than $2,000 a year when it does fly, which is, by the way, one of the big reasons it's not flying now.

My 2004 Chevy Cavalier costs me about $650 a year to insure.

So it's hard to see where the market is for this air/car among the general population.

"Great idea," a commenter on the Ted Talks website said. "Early adopting might have some issues, but will be a great way to solve traffic issues."

No, it won't, actually. The only place where it'd be legal to take off is at an airport. You can't, for example, see a traffic jam ahead, and decide to unfold the wings and take off.

Anna Mracek Dietrich says an advantage is if pilots encounter bad weather, "just land and drive home." Fair enough. But that will most certainly lead its owners to head out on a flight when the weather is questionable, and that's never been a very good idea. Alternately, a pilot who might fly often in bad weather, could get training and instrument rating for a fraction of the cost of the Terrafugia.

The company says over 100 people have put down deposits on the Terrafugia.

(7 Comments)