News Cut: August 19, 2008 Archive

Should the drinking age be lowered to 18?

Posted at 7:53 AM on August 19, 2008 by Bob Collins (25 Comments)

College presidents around the country are pushing for a lower drinking age. They say it would lower the amount of binge drinking going on. This issue, of course, is of prime concern to the Upper Midwest, where binge drinking far exceeds the national average.

The movement called the Amethyst Initiative began quietly recruiting presidents more than a year ago, the Associated Press reports.

"This is a law that is routinely evaded," said John McCardell, former president of Middlebury College in Vermont who started the organization. "It is a law that the people at whom it is directed believe is unjust and unfair and discriminatory."

Other prominent schools in the group include Syracuse, Tufts, Colgate, Kenyon and Morehouse.

But even before the presidents begin the public phase of their efforts, which may include publishing newspaper ads in the coming weeks, they are already facing sharp criticism.

It's unlike the idea is going to get a lot of support from politicians. A survey out today shows parents are "fed up" with party schools and politicians who advocate a lower drinking age.

Take the survey:

(Update: See the signatories below the fold.)

Continue reading "Should the drinking age be lowered to 18?"

Melody's Olympics: What might have been

Posted at 1:03 PM on August 19, 2008 by Bob Collins (1 Comments)
Filed under: Sports

MPR's Melody Ng is in China on vacation. But nobody is allowed to go on vacation at MPR without sending material back to News Cut. Here is today's dispatch from Beijing.

8-19-08 Great Wall at Simatai. Liu Shuying is two years younger than I am. Her son is 12. Her husband grows corn on a small plot of land. And she climbs the Great Wall several times a day, following tourists, offering helpful (or not so helpful) tips on directions and vantage points, sharing bits of Wall history, and often, lending an arm to support ascent or descent of a particularly steep spot. She and her 73 colleagues may spend several hours of their time with a group, whether tourists want them around or not (it was the latter with us today), just so they can attempt to sell an "I climbed the Great Wall" t-shirt, fan, or pair of chopsticks at the end of the trip.

Liu Shuying is surprisingly upbeat about her situation. She's the third of four sisters. Her father farmed - back then it was more wheat (I'm petty sure that's the grain she was describing) than corn. He died when she was 23. She got married that same year, and had to move to her husband's village on the opposite side of the Great Wall - what, when the wall was built during the Ming Dynasty, had been the Chinese side (her family had lived on what was the outside side of the wall - the side that belonged to the barbarians of the north.)

Ms. Liu follows tourists around because she says she has no other way to make a living. There are no factories in the area, and farming their tiny bit of land yields little. She tries to be helpful (I'm convinced she's sincere in her efforts), but mostly ends up being a pest because the whole reason we choose to come out to Simatai, the most isolated section of the Great Wall near Beijing that's open to tourists, is because we don't want to be around a bunch of people when we're taking in what has to be one of the most amazing and beautiful feats of humankind.

When I visited Simatai 14 years ago, it had just opened to tourists, and was basically a partially restored wall with numerous intact guard towers, known for its steep climbs and lack of infrastructure that surrounds most Chinese tourist attractions. My friend Ben and I had to take a crowded long distance bus that locals use to travel between cities out to the Wall. It was January, gray and cold. We were the only people there other than members of an Air France flight crew that I thought were the most elegant people I had ever met. No one was selling entrance tickets. No one was selling anything. No one was even around. We climbed until we could go no further, and then realized that we had no way to travel the two hours back to Beijing, and Benny had a flight to Israel he had to catch that night. I still smile whenever I see an Air France plane because those kind people rescued us by standing up to the wrath of their Chinese driver and giving us a ride back to town.

Now Simatai (admission 40 RMB, or about $5.75 per person) has a cable sky cab line to speed your trip up, and a zip wire line to speed your trip down. It has vendor stalls, a post office, two guest houses, and a dam upon which you can take a "cruise." It has a delegation of persistent guide women like Liu Shuying. And now, during the Olympics, it also has an official information booth where blue jerseyed volunteers continually update Olympic medal counts.

As I speak with Liu Shuying this afternoon, I wonder (as I often do while people watching in China), how similar would my life be to hers if my great grandfather had not come to the U.S. to try to better his life? That thought usually helps me empathize with people that I find rude or annoying or worse. Today it mostly just makes me wish that Ms. Liu was carrying around better souvenirs in her bag of wares.

Comment on this post

Delegate profile: Bethany Dorobiala

Posted at 10:25 PM on August 19, 2008 by Bob Collins (1 Comments)
Filed under: Politics, The political conventions

Another in a continuing series of profiles of Minnesota delegates to the national political conventions.

Name: Bethany Dorobiala

Party: Republican (Alternate delegate)

Hometown: Woodbury (Now living in Burnsville)

Representing: 6th District

Age: 21 (Youngest in the Minnesota delegation)

Occupation: Student (political science) at the University of Minnesota. Chairman, Minnesota College Republicans. "We have a chapter in almost every campus in the state. We face a lot of struggles with campus administrations and student opinion on campus. Once we put out a positive image of what Republicans stand for, we get a lot of support." Listen

How she became a delegate: I ran for alternate. I knew that especially this election year, it's important for youth to be represented as part of this campaign. i wanted to make sure students had a voice. I ran for an at-large alternate position. Sen. Obama hadn't been announced as a presumptive nominee but it was close, so I knew how important students were going to be in this election. Listen

Political roots: Has always been interested in politics. "I got started in a YMCA program called Youth in Government. It models state government. We had a chance to sit in the halls of the state Capitol and talk about issues students are passionate about."

"A lot of my values stem from how I raised by my parents but not something that was enforced by them by any means; the values they instilled in me -- personal responsibility, fiscal conservatism, taking care of one another -- has led me to the Republican Party." Listen

What she's most looking forward to at the RNC: I've been following the preparations since St. Paul was named the host city. I'm excited to have the party rally here. I'm proud to be able to host the leaders of the party. All the different things going on are exciting to see take shape." Listen

Favorite book: To Kill a Mockingbird

Favorite movie: An American in Paris.

Favorite music: County. "I like a band called Little Big Town."

Most influential person. "My mom. She's an incredibly hard worker and I've tried to model my life similar to how she lives her life."

Bucket list: I want to travel the world. I think Americans don't value how lucky we are to live in America and the freedoms we're able to enjoy."

Comment on this post