News Cut: November 27, 2007 Archive

Privacy leaks: The price of incompetence

Posted at 10:44 AM on November 27, 2007 by Bob Collins (0 Comments)

Back in 1999, when we were putting together The Surveillance Society project at MPR, privacy concerns were still in a quaint stage. We figured the threats to our privacy were surreptitious individuals mining the data after hacking into some giant mainframe somewhere and stealing nuggets about ourselves. It's still true. It's a threat.

We didn't imagine that the data that would be stolen was quite often the information we willingly give and that it would fall into the hands of others primarily because of simple incompetence of those who collected it.

In the U.K. last week, the personal data of 25 million citizens -- everyone in the country who receives child benefits -- disappeared when a clerk in the Revenues and Customs Department mailed (as in snail mailed!) the disks. They didn't show up at the audit agency that was supposed to audit them and nobody knows where they are. "This is the biggest privacy disaster by our government," said Jonathan Bamford, assistant information commissioner. Right.

Certainly some federal bureacrats in this country can relate. Last year, 26.5 million veterans had their Social Security numbers leak when a Veterans Affairs employee took the laptop with the data home. The home was burglarized and the data disappeared.

There are, of course, actual bad guys out there trying to steal your private information. But the real problem, according to Ben Worthen at the Wall Street Journal, is employees of the government and private companies don't understand the value of your data in the first place.

The perception problem: When workers lose a computer disk or a portable storage device such as a USB memory stick, they seem to look at the $20 it will cost to replace the device, not the value of the data inside it. (It’s like valuing that theoretical $10 million shipment by the cost of the briefcase and not by the cash inside.)

Maybe the bosses should see this online calculator, which calculates the cost of any privacy breach to a company.

Comment on this post

Diversity in Minnesota courts

Posted at 4:04 PM on November 27, 2007 by Bob Collins (0 Comments)

Mark Cohen, the editor at Minnesota Lawyer, penned a fine column a week or so ago on diversity in Minnesota's court system.

After acknowledging the obvious requirements to be a Supreme Court justice, Cohen wrote...

Diversity is probably the biggest other factor that is on the mind of the legal community. With Hanson's departure, the court will be left with one African American justice (who gained his seat through election rather than appointment), two women justices and three justices with the surname of Anderson. There has never been an African American, Native American, Hispanic or Asian candidate appointed to the Minnesota high court -- an odd situation given that there are so many qualified lawyers in each of these groups.

That record is intact. Today, the governor made his selection. Chris Dietzen, an Appeals Court judge and his onetime campaign attorney, got the nod.

Pawlenty made four district court appointments today, picking prosecutor Janet Barke Cain for a new judicial slot in Carver County, private attorney Tim Wermager for a new position in Dakota County, GOP state Sen. Tom Neuville for an opening in Rice County and private attorney Jerome Abrams for a judgeship in Scott County.

All are said to be highly qualified, and none expands the diversity of Minnesota courts.

Comment on this post