The Bleacher Bums Header

Twins lineup is out of order

Posted at 9:54 AM on June 6, 2007 by Steve Rudolph

Joe Mauer is rehabbing his strained left quadriceps muscle in Florida and could return to the Twins lineup this Friday. When he rejoins the team, all indications are that he’ll reclaim the No. 3 spot in the batting order.

The move makes absolutely no sense!

If Ron Gardenhire wants to give his team the best chance to score runs each night, he won’t get hung up on tradition, will take my advice and that of columnists and blogeers, and bat Mauer second instead.


1. Batting Mauer second actually gets him more at-bats, which isn’t a bad thing for a guy who led the league in hitting last season and was hitting .353 with a .446 OBP this season before getting hurt.

2. Nick Punto is not the same hitter he was in 2006. He’s not even close. He’s batting a paltry .226 and strikes out once in every six plate appearances. (I could go on and on about his failed bunt attempts, swings at balls in the dirt and overall offensive futility, but I’ll save that rant for a future post.)

3. Jeff Cirillo isn’t much better than Nick Punto. Gardy tried Cirillo in this spot on the road trip with a measure of success. He can put down a bunt and doesn’t strike out that often. But that’s virtually all he’s contributed. Cirillo’s batting average is starting to make Nick Punto look like the second-coming of Lou Gehrig.

4. Please don’t hate me St. Paul, but Joe Mauer doesn’t hit for power. As much as everyone in baseball believes he’ll eventually become more of a power hitter, he isn’t one now nor has he even been one in his professional career. He does put the ball in play and can spray it to all fields, characteristics of a good No. 2 hitter. Having him bat second would allow Gardenhire to put more plays on when Luis Castillo leads off the game with a hit or walk. And that dovetails into my next item.

5. I’d much rather see Justin Morneau come to the plate with a runner on base and two outs in the first inning, while batting cleanup, than see him lead off the following inning as the Twins No. 5 hitter. Morneau was among the league leaders in 2-out RBIs last year. Batting Mauer second only gives the A.L. MVP more swings in the first inning to stake his team, and young pitching staff, to a lead.

6. Joe Mauer is far more like Rod Carew than Kirby Puckett. Although nearly as popular as Puckett was at his peak, Joe Mauer doesn’t drive in runs the way Kirby did when he anchored the third spot in the lineup all those years. Instead Mauer’s hitting is much more like another Twins great and former batting champ, Rod Carew. And where in the order did Carew get most of his ABs? This might come as a shock, but Carew hit second in 1149 games throughout his career, compared to only 679 in the No. 3 spot, and somehow managed to find his way to the hall of fame.

7. Batting second doesn’t mean a batter has to give himself up at the plate. Rod Carew didn’t amass 3053 hits by squaring around to bunt every game. He did put the ball in play and got a lot of singles and doubles. As it stands now, Mauer probably bunts more than any No. 3 hitter in the game.

I never said this was a top ten list and since seven is a lucky number, and Mauer’s jersey number, I’ll stop and leave it to you to add any more reasons why Gardy should take our advice.

June 2007
          1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30

Master Archive

MPR News

Listen Now

On Air


Other Radio Streams from MPR

Classical MPR
Radio Heartland